Broadway Audience Scorecard
What real theatergoers think. Combined AudienceGrade ratings from Show Score, Mezzanine, Theatr, Broadway.com, and Reddit.
28 shows · 440,428+ audience reviews · Updated August 9, 2026
How AudienceGrade Works
We combine 5 audience sources into a single AudienceGrade letter grade. Each source is weighted proportionally by its number of reviews — more reviews means more influence. No single source can exceed 80% of the total weight.
Show Score
Audience reviews with detailed 0-100 scores. Often the largest sample size.
Mezzanine
iOS app with verified ticket holders rating shows 1-5 stars.
Theatr
Broadway community app with three-way sentiment: like, dislike, or mixed.
Broadway.com
Star ratings from verified ticket buyers on Broadway’s largest ticket site.
Sentiment analysis from Reddit theatre communities (r/Broadway, r/TheWestEnd). Requires 50+ comments. Excluded for shows closed 3+ years.
All Shows by AudienceGrade
Click column headers to sort. Shows ranked by combined AudienceGrade rating.
Shows by Grade
Audience data aggregated from Show Score, Mezzanine, Theatr, Broadway.com, Reddit. Sources weighted proportionally by review count (80% cap per source). Updated weekly.