Skip to main content
All Shows

Best Broadway Shows for First-Timers

Never been to a Broadway show before? Welcome! These productions are perfect for first-time theatergoers. We've selected shows that are accessible, entertaining, and representative of what makes Broadway special. These aren't just "beginner" shows - they're critically acclaimed productions that happen to be particularly welcoming to newcomers. With engaging stories, spectacular staging, and universal themes, these shows will leave you excited to come back for more.

18 shows | Last updated: August 2026

Sort:
How This Works

Shows are ranked by CriticScore, a weighted average of reviews from dozens of outlets. Top-tier publications (NYT, Vulture, Variety) carry more weight than smaller outlets. Toggle to Audience mode to see letter grades based on audience sentiment from multiple sources.

Learn about our scoring methodology →