Skip to main content
All Shows

Tony Winning Shows Now on Broadway

The Tony Awards represent the highest honors in American theater, and these shows have earned Broadway's most prestigious accolades. Whether they won Best Musical, Best Play, or collected multiple awards for their creative teams, these productions represent the pinnacle of theatrical achievement. Seeing a Tony winner is a chance to experience shows that have been recognized as the very best Broadway has to offer.

10 shows | Last updated: August 2026

Sort:
Hamilton Broadway musical

Hamilton

11 years on Broadway
Critical Gold
92
Audience:A+
The Book of Mormon Broadway musical

The Book of Mormon

15+ years on Broadway
Critical Gold
88
Audience:A-
Chicago Broadway musical

Chicago

REVIVAL
29+ years on Broadway
Critical Gold
87
Audience:B+
Maybe Happy Ending Broadway musical

Maybe Happy Ending

1+ year on Broadway
Critical Gold
87
Audience:A+
The Lion King Broadway musical

The Lion King

28+ years on Broadway
Critical Gold
84
Audience:A
Hadestown Broadway musical

Hadestown

7+ years on Broadway
Critical Gold
83
Audience:A+
Buena Vista Social Club Broadway musical

Buena Vista Social Club

1+ year on Broadway· Closes Jan 13, 2027
Recommended
82
Audience:A+
SIX Broadway musical

SIX

4+ years on Broadway
Recommended
82
Audience:A-
Moulin Rouge! The Musical Broadway musical

Moulin Rouge! The Musical

7+ years on Broadway· Closes Aug 30, 2026
Worth Seeing
72
Audience:B+
The Outsiders Broadway musical

The Outsiders

2+ years on Broadway· Closes Jan 15, 2027
Worth Seeing
71
Audience:A+

See Also

SoundtracksRevivalsMust-See Shows for Tourists
How This Works

Shows are ranked by CriticScore, a weighted average of reviews from dozens of outlets. Top-tier publications (NYT, Vulture, Variety) carry more weight than smaller outlets. Toggle to Audience mode to see letter grades based on audience sentiment from multiple sources.

Learn about our scoring methodology →