Broadway Show Comparisons
Can't decide between two shows? Compare CriticScore ratings, runtime, ticket prices, and lottery availability side by side to find the perfect show for you.
Compare Any Two Shows
Hamilton vs Wicked? Type any two shows to see which critics prefer.
Most Popular Matchups
The comparisons Broadway fans search for most
Hamilton vs Wicked
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 92 vs 63
The Lion King vs Aladdin
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 83 vs 70
The Lion King vs Wicked
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 83 vs 63
Hamilton vs The Lion King
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 92 vs 83
Wicked vs Aladdin
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 63 vs 70
Hamilton vs Moulin Rouge! The Musical
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 92 vs 74
Current Hits
Compare the hottest shows playing now
Operation Mincemeat vs SIX
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 76 vs 82
Operation Mincemeat vs Hadestown
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 76 vs 83
Buena Vista Social Club vs Moulin Rouge! The Musical
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 82 vs 74
Buena Vista Social Club vs Hadestown
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 82 vs 83
Ragtime vs Hamilton
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 83 vs 92
Chess vs SIX
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 64 vs 82
Schmigadoon! vs SIX
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 79 vs 82
Schmigadoon! vs & Juliet
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 79 vs 71
Titanique vs SIX
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 76 vs 82
CATS: The Jellicle Ball vs The Lion King
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 86 vs 83
Death Becomes Her vs Chicago
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 80 vs 87
Maybe Happy Ending vs Hadestown
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 87 vs 83
The Great Gatsby vs Moulin Rouge! The Musical
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 58 vs 74
Hell's Kitchen vs MJ The Musical
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 78 vs 67
Hell's Kitchen vs SIX
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 78 vs 82
Family Shows
Finding the right show for kids and families
The Lion King vs Harry Potter and the Cursed Child
Musical vs Play• Scores: 83 vs 85
Aladdin vs Harry Potter and the Cursed Child
Musical vs Play• Scores: 70 vs 85
Wicked vs Harry Potter and the Cursed Child
Musical vs Play• Scores: 63 vs 85
Aladdin vs SIX
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 70 vs 82
The Lion King vs Beetlejuice
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 83 vs 60
Aladdin vs Beetlejuice
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 70 vs 60
The Lion King vs MJ The Musical
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 83 vs 67
Aladdin vs MJ The Musical
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 70 vs 67
Musicals Head-to-Head
The great musical debates
Hadestown vs Moulin Rouge! The Musical
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 83 vs 74
Hadestown vs Wicked
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 83 vs 63
Hadestown vs Hamilton
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 83 vs 92
The Book of Mormon vs Hamilton
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 88 vs 92
The Book of Mormon vs Wicked
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 88 vs 63
SIX vs Hadestown
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 82 vs 83
MJ The Musical vs Hadestown
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 67 vs 83
MJ The Musical vs Moulin Rouge! The Musical
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 67 vs 74
& Juliet vs MJ The Musical
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 71 vs 67
& Juliet vs Moulin Rouge! The Musical
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 71 vs 74
More Comparisons
Even more head-to-head matchups
Chicago vs Moulin Rouge! The Musical
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 87 vs 74
Chicago vs Wicked
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 87 vs 63
Chicago vs Hamilton
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 87 vs 92
The Lion King vs Moulin Rouge! The Musical
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 83 vs 74
SIX vs & Juliet
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 82 vs 71
The Outsiders vs Water for Elephants
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 71 vs 75
Hell's Kitchen vs The Outsiders
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 78 vs 71
Hell's Kitchen vs Hadestown
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 78 vs 83
Oh, Mary! vs Cabaret at the Kit Kat Club
Play vs Musical• Scores: 88 vs 64
Maybe Happy Ending vs The Notebook
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 87 vs 63
Stranger Things: The First Shadow vs Beetlejuice
Play vs Musical• Scores: 65 vs 60
MJ The Musical vs SIX
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 67 vs 82
Harry Potter and the Cursed Child vs Stranger Things: The First Shadow
Play vs Play• Scores: 85 vs 65
Stereophonic vs Appropriate
Play vs Play• Scores: 89 vs 86
Death of a Salesman vs Oedipus
Play vs Play• Scores: 86 vs 81
Cabaret at the Kit Kat Club vs Chicago
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 64 vs 87
Sweeney Todd vs Hadestown
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 82 vs 83
Sunset Boulevard vs Chicago
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 76 vs 87
Sunset Boulevard vs Cabaret at the Kit Kat Club
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 76 vs 64
Hamilton vs Harry Potter and the Cursed Child
Musical vs Play• Scores: 92 vs 85
Wicked vs Stranger Things: The First Shadow
Musical vs Play• Scores: 63 vs 65
The Phantom of the Opera vs Les Misérables
Musical vs Musical
Rent vs Dear Evan Hansen
Musical vs Musical
Come From Away vs Dear Evan Hansen
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 79 vs 87
Jersey Boys vs MJ The Musical
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 80 vs 67
Mean Girls vs SIX
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 76 vs 82
Frozen vs Aladdin
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 64 vs 70
Beetlejuice vs Mean Girls
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 60 vs 76
Dog Day Afternoon vs Oh, Mary!
Play vs Play• Scores: 52 vs 88
Dog Day Afternoon vs The Outsiders
Play vs Musical• Scores: 52 vs 71
Beaches, A New Musical vs Death Becomes Her
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 44 vs 80
The Lost Boys vs Beetlejuice
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 72 vs 60
The Lost Boys vs Stranger Things: The First Shadow
Musical vs Play• Scores: 72 vs 65
The Balusters vs Stereophonic
Play vs Play• Scores: 79 vs 89
Death Becomes Her vs Beetlejuice
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 80 vs 60
The Great Gatsby vs Death Becomes Her
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 58 vs 80
Sunset Boulevard vs The Great Gatsby
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 76 vs 58
Oh, Mary! vs Stereophonic
Play vs Play• Scores: 88 vs 89
Cabaret at the Kit Kat Club vs Hadestown
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 64 vs 83
Water for Elephants vs Moulin Rouge! The Musical
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 75 vs 74
Wicked vs Moulin Rouge! The Musical
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 63 vs 74
Hamilton vs SIX
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 92 vs 82
Hamilton vs Cabaret at the Kit Kat Club
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 92 vs 64
The Book of Mormon vs SIX
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 88 vs 82
The Book of Mormon vs Moulin Rouge! The Musical
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 88 vs 74
Hadestown vs The Outsiders
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 83 vs 71
SIX vs Wicked
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 82 vs 63
Wicked vs Beetlejuice
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 63 vs 60
MJ The Musical vs Hamilton
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 67 vs 92
The Lion King vs SIX
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 83 vs 82
The Lion King vs Hadestown
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 83 vs 83
Dear Evan Hansen vs Hadestown
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 87 vs 83
Come From Away vs Hadestown
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 79 vs 83
Come From Away vs Hamilton
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 79 vs 92
Sweeney Todd vs Cabaret at the Kit Kat Club
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 82 vs 64
Stereophonic vs The Outsiders
Play vs Musical• Scores: 89 vs 71
Hell's Kitchen vs Maybe Happy Ending
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 78 vs 87
The Notebook vs Water for Elephants
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 63 vs 75
Rent vs Hamilton
Musical vs Musical
The Phantom of the Opera vs Wicked
Musical vs Musical
Les Misérables vs Hamilton
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 74 vs 92
& Juliet vs Beetlejuice
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 71 vs 60
Beetlejuice vs Hadestown
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 60 vs 83
MJ The Musical vs The Outsiders
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 67 vs 71
Mean Girls vs & Juliet
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 76 vs 71
Jersey Boys vs & Juliet
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 80 vs 71
Jersey Boys vs SIX
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 80 vs 82
Aladdin vs Mean Girls
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 70 vs 76
Ragtime vs Hadestown
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 83 vs 83
Chess vs Hamilton
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 64 vs 92
Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York) vs Maybe Happy Ending
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 77 vs 87
Titanique vs & Juliet
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 76 vs 71
CATS: The Jellicle Ball vs SIX
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 86 vs 82
Beaches, A New Musical vs Moulin Rouge! The Musical
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 44 vs 74
The Rocky Horror Show vs Beetlejuice
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 71 vs 60
The Lost Boys vs Death Becomes Her
Musical vs Musical• Scores: 72 vs 80
Death of a Salesman vs The Great Gatsby
Play vs Musical• Scores: 86 vs 58
Giant vs The Outsiders
Play vs Musical• Scores: 78 vs 71
Looking for more options? Browse all Broadway shows by category.