All Gold Lists
Off-Broadway Critical Gold List™
The highest-rated Off-Broadway shows by professional critics
6 shows | 2023-2024 Season
1
Oh, Mary!
PLAYORIGINALCLOSED
Closed May 2024 · Opened Feb 2024
Critical Gold
88
2
CATS: The Jellicle Ball
MUSICALREVIVALCLOSED
Closed Aug 2024 · Opened Jun 2024
Critical Gold
87
3
Buena Vista Social Club
MUSICALORIGINALCLOSED
Closed Jan 2024 · Opened Dec 2023
Critical Gold
83
Sunset Baby
PLAYORIGINALCLOSED
Closed Mar 2024 · Opened Feb 2024
Recommended
79
Stereophonic
MUSICALORIGINALCLOSED
Closed Dec 2023 · Opened Oct 2023
Recommended
76
The Lonely Few
MUSICALORIGINALCLOSED
Closed Jun 2024 · Opened May 2024
Worth Seeing
73