All Gold Lists
Off-Broadway Critical Gold List™
The highest-rated Off-Broadway shows by professional critics
10 shows | 2025-2026 Season
1
Misterman (Theatre Row)
PLAYORIGINALCLOSED
Closed Jul 2026 · Opened Jun 2026
Critical Gold
95
2
The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee
MUSICALREVIVALNOW PLAYING
Closes Oct 2026 · Opened Nov 2025
Critical Gold
91
3
Hold On To Your Butts
PLAYORIGINALCLOSED
Closed Mar 2026 · Opened Feb 2026
Critical Gold
90
Madama Butterfly
OPERAORIGINALCLOSED
Closed Mar 2026 · Opened Jan 2026
Critical Gold
89
Well, I'll Let You Go
PLAYORIGINALCLOSED
Closed Jun 2026 · Opened Apr 2026
Critical Gold
88
Andrea Chénier
OPERAORIGINALCLOSED
Closed Dec 2025 · Opened Nov 2025
Critical Gold
87
Silver Manhattan
PLAYORIGINALCLOSED
Closed May 2026 · Opened Feb 2026
Critical Gold
87
Making a Show of Myself
PLAYORIGINALCLOSED
Closed Mar 2026 · Opened Feb 2026
Critical Gold
86
Porgy and Bess
OPERAORIGINALCLOSED
Closed Jan 2026 · Opened Dec 2025
Critical Gold
86
Hate Radio
PLAYORIGINALCLOSED
Closed Feb 2026 · Opened Feb 2026
Critical Gold
85