“I Made You A Mixtape is innovative, daring, and compelling.” By Ruth Sealey, Jun 15 · 4/5 stars
PLAYOff-WECLOSED
I Made You a Mixtape
Opened Jun 12, 2026 · Closed Jun 14, 2026 · Ran for less than a month
3 Positive
1 Mixed
Critics' Take
This nostalgic 90s-fueled dance piece divides critics, with some embracing its joyful energy and movement-driven storytelling, while others find the execution falls short of its promising concept.
This show has closed. Tickets are no longer available.
Critic Scorecard
4 reviews3 Positive
1 Mixed
Sort:
Weighted by outlet tier · Counts
- Tier 1: 100%
- Tier 2: 75%
- Tier 3: 40%
- Tier 4: 20%
“This is a show that invites you to the party as a guest, not simply an audience member.” By Louise Penn, Jun 15 · 4/5 stars
“Despite the minor drawbacks, the show is an experimental triumph.” By Bobby Tee, Jun 17 · 3/5 stars
“If I Made You a Mixtape wants us to join the party, it needs to do more than recreate it.” By Camille Leadbeater, Jun 16 · 2/5 stars
