“One of Payne's finest plays though, The Unbelievers confirms the Royal Court's new phase can again splice the traditionally-crafted with the exploratory. A must-see.” By Simon Jenner, Nov 4, 2025

The Unbelievers
Opened Oct 16, 2025 · Closed Nov 29, 2025 · Ran for 1 month
Critics' Take
Walker delivers a powerhouse performance in Payne's time-fractured drama about a mother unable to move on from her missing son, but critics find the play uneven—praised for its emotional intensity and dark humor yet criticized for lacking the elegance of his earlier work.
This show has closed. Tickets are no longer available.
Critic Scorecard
25 reviews- Tier 1: 100%
- Tier 2: 75%
- Tier 3: 40%
- Tier 4: 20%
“Thankfully, The Unbelievers lives up to expectations; insightful, humane, dramatic and surprisingly funny, this story of a missing child is so admirably crafted, it has it all.” By Edward Lukes, Oct 25, 2025
“I am so glad to have experienced it – a play to remember for a long time, especially the next time I read or hear of someone who is ‘missing’ or ‘disappeared’.” By John Groves, Oct 22, 2025
“I, for one, believe in the gathering power with which The Unbelievers argues its unflinching case, and Walker's complete embrace of this role is itself a thing of wonder.” By Matt Wolf, Oct 23, 20254/5 stars
“When Walker gnaws a fingernail, it seems as though she might devour an entire finger without noticing.” By Fiona Mountford, Oct 21, 20254/5 stars





