2023–24 Broadway Award Scorecard

Which shows dominated the 2023–24 Broadway awards season? Each score weighs seven ceremonies — Tonys, Pulitzer, Olivier, Drama Desk, OCC, Drama League, and NYDCC — with Tony wins carrying the most weight.

35 shows with award activity

Filter35 shows

#	Show↕	Award Score↓	Tier	Notable	Tony Record
1	Stereophonic Sweeper CLOSED2023-24	91	Sweeper	Pulitzer Finalist	5 Wins · 13 Noms
2	Merrily We Roll Along Decorated CLOSED2023-24	82	Decorated	4 Tony Wins	4 Wins · 7 Noms
3	The Outsiders Decorated NOW PLAYING2023-24	81	Decorated	4 Tony Wins	4 Wins · 12 Noms
4	Appropriate Decorated CLOSED2023-24	81	Decorated	3 Tony Wins	3 Wins · 8 Noms
5	Suffs Decorated CLOSED2023-24	79	Decorated	Tony · Best Book	2 Wins · 6 Noms
6	Hell's Kitchen Decorated CLOSED2023-24	74	Decorated	Tony · Lead Performance	2 Wins · 13 Noms
7	Mary Jane Honored CLOSED2023-24	64	Honored	NYDCC Winner	0 Wins · 4 Noms
8	Cabaret at the Kit Kat Club Honored CLOSED2023-24	62	Honored	Tony · Best Scenic Design of a …	1 Win · 9 Noms
9	Illinoise Honored CLOSED2023-24	60	Honored	Tony · Best Choreography	1 Win · 4 Noms
10	Water for Elephants Honored CLOSED2023-24	60	Honored	—	0 Wins · 7 Noms
11	An Enemy of the People Honored CLOSED2023-24	60	Honored	Tony · Lead Performance	1 Win · 5 Noms
12	Prayer for the French Republic Honored CLOSED2023-24	60	Honored	—	0 Wins · 3 Noms
13	Purlie Victorious: A Non-Confederate Romp Through the Cotton Patch Honored CLOSED2023-24	60	Honored	Tony · Featured Performance	1 Win · 6 Noms
14	Mother Play Honored CLOSED2023-24	58	Honored	—	0 Wins · 4 Noms
15	Days of Wine and Roses Honored CLOSED2023-24	54	Honored	—	0 Wins · 3 Noms
16	Jaja's African Hair Braiding Honored CLOSED2023-24	53	Honored	Tony · Best Costume Design of a…	1 Win · 5 Noms
17	The Great Gatsby Honored NOW PLAYING2023-24	47	Honored	Tony · Best Costume Design of a…	1 Win · 1 Nom
18	The Who's Tommy Honored CLOSED2023-24	44	Honored	—	0 Wins · 1 Nom
19	Real Women Have Curves Nominated CLOSED2023-24	43	Nominated	—	0 Wins · 2 Noms
20	The Notebook Nominated CLOSED2023-24	43	Nominated	—	0 Wins · 3 Noms
21	Gutenberg! The Musical! Nominated CLOSED2023-24	41	Nominated	—	0 Wins · 1 Nom
22	Doubt: A Parable Nominated CLOSED2023-24	40	Nominated	—	0 Wins · 3 Noms
23	SMASH Honored CLOSED2023-24	39	Honored	—	0 Wins · 2 Noms
24	Back to the Future: The Musical Nominated CLOSED2023-24	28	Nominated	—	0 Wins · 2 Noms
25	A Wonderful World: The Louis Armstrong Musical Nominated CLOSED2023-24	20	Nominated	—	0 Wins · 1 Nom
26	Swept Away Nominated CLOSED2023-24	19	Nominated	—	0 Wins · 1 Nom
27	The Heart of Rock and Roll Nominated CLOSED2023-24	18	Nominated	—	—
28	The Wiz Nominated CLOSED2023-24	18	Nominated	—	—
29	Harmony Nominated CLOSED2023-24	14	Nominated	—	—
30	The Shark Is Broken Nominated CLOSED2023-24	14	Nominated	—	—
31	How to Dance in Ohio Nominated CLOSED2023-24	13	Nominated	—	—
32	The Cottage Nominated CLOSED2023-24	12	Nominated	—	—
33	I Need That Nominated CLOSED2023-24	10	Nominated	—	—
34	Just for Us Nominated CLOSED2023-24	10	Nominated	—	—
35	Once Upon a One More Time Nominated CLOSED2023-24	10	Nominated	—	—

← All Seasons Tony Predictions →How Scoring Works →