Best Broadway Shows of the 1990s

Every Broadway show that opened during the 1990s (1990–1999), ranked by aggregated CriticScore ratings from dozens of professional critics. This decade saw some of Broadway's most celebrated productions — from groundbreaking musicals to powerful dramas and revivals that redefined what theater could be. Whether you lived through this era or are discovering it for the first time, these rankings reveal which shows stood the test of critical scrutiny.

3 shows | Last updated: September 2026