Skip to main content
AT

Aramide Tinubu

Reviews

50

Average

77

Highest

94

Lowest

25

101st most prolific critic·837th most generous scorer
SORT:
Joe Turner's Come and Gone

“Bursting with heart and humor, the production showcases all of the intricacies and beauty of Black American life, the never-ending costs of slavery, racism and discrimination and how Black people flourish and move forward despite it all.”

Proof
Proof

Variety · Apr 16, 2026

71

“'Proof' remains a scintillating play. Its questions about hereditary mental illness, the truth, and who can be labeled a genius — especially with a Black woman at the center — continue to resonate.”

The Fear of 13
The Fear of 13

Variety · Apr 15, 2026

74

“‘The Fear of 13’ is deeply moving. Yet it falls short of being remarkable with uneven pacing and its ever-shifting tone.”

Every Brilliant Thing

“Award-winner Daniel Radcliffe, the solo production is unique and thrilling, reminding viewers of life's magical and, yes, brilliant delights.”

Bug
Bug

Variety · Jan 8, 2026

85

“Manic, disturbing and relentless, ‘Bug’ gets under the audience’s skin and remains there long after the final curtain drops.”

The Queen of Versailles

“Unfortunately, Greenfield’s dazzling assessment of greed, consumption and the American dream doesn’t translate on the stage.”

Liberation
Liberation

Variety · Oct 28, 2025

85

“‘Liberation’ is a brilliant, well-acted, and sobering account of the women’s rights movement, complicity, and the lens through which we view our caretakers — namely, our mothers.”

Purpose
Purpose

Variety · Mar 17, 2025

90

“‘Purpose’ is a brilliant and profound narrative about legacies, ambition, mental illness and who you may become if you were never allowed to know yourself.”

Gypsy
Gypsy

Variety · Dec 20, 2024

92

“The latest revival is an electric and truly unique production that will undoubtedly become a crowning jewel in the canon of 'Gypsy.'”

Cult of Love
Cult of Love

Variety · Dec 19, 2024

75

“There is so much good and sharp in ‘Cult of Love’ — its treatment of grown siblings reckoning with their parents, its tactical observations about how in-laws fit into a family unit — that its slack moments rankle somewhat.”

Swept Away
Swept Away

Variety · Nov 19, 2024

73

“People will come to see 'Swept Away' for the music, and they'll be glad they did. And they'll come for the acting, too, which is accomplished and polished.”

Tammy Faye
Tammy Faye

Variety · Nov 15, 2024

41

“The songs are undistinguished and unrooted in character, filled with generic and immediately forgettable power ballads, Christian pop tunes and revivalist floor stompers.”

Maybe Happy Ending
85

“‘Maybe Happy Ending’ is an undeniably moving, well-made, adorable musical, and it is a pleasant surprise to see an audience weep at a show about two robots in love.”

Our Town
Our Town

Variety · Oct 10, 2024

79

“Life is fragile and fleeting, and love is all that matters.”

Sunset Boulevard
93

“Scherzinger has plainly been waiting for the right stage, and she puts every bit of fierceness and charisma into proving herself.”

McNeal
McNeal

Variety · Sep 30, 2024

25

“While beautifully staged and produced, ‘McNeal’ is a dull and garbled play that says very little about ethics and artificial intelligence and instead hoists up a pompous and exhausting man who has only ever cared about himself and his legacy.”

The Roommate
The Roommate

Variety · Sep 13, 2024

78

“In the main, ‘The Roommate’ is a spirited entry on Broadway and a welcome showcase for LuPone and — in particular”

Oh, Mary!
Oh, Mary!

Variety · Jul 10, 2024

91

“The play itself is a masterclass in comedy, relying on the impeccable timing of the actors to keep each joke perfectly in tune with the audience.”

Mother Play
Mother Play

Variety · Apr 25, 2024

72

“Lange is magnificent in her depiction of a woman who, across the decades, can’t quite reconcile what her life or her children have become.”

Mary Jane
Mary Jane

Variety · Apr 23, 2024

77

“‘Mary Jane’ stays with viewers long after they leave the theater.”

Hell's Kitchen
Hell's Kitchen

Variety · Apr 20, 2024

85

“Instead, ‘Hell’s Kitchen’ is a sparkling story paying homage to New York, to that beautiful and heartbreaking transition between girlhood and womanhood and to the women who hold our hands through it all.”

Suffs
Suffs

Variety · Apr 18, 2024

90

“It's evident in its inventive storytelling, combined with its musical richness and emotional engagement, fueled by the vigor of brilliant outsiders demanding their place not only in history but on Broadway.”

The Notebook
The Notebook

Variety · Mar 14, 2024

44

“But without leading characters, story or songs that are elevated, this love story remains not only leaden but as slight as jottings in journal.”

Doubt: A Parable
74

“Uncomfortable and thought-provoking, the themes of ‘Doubt’ have never been more urgent.”

Appropriate
Appropriate

Variety · Dec 18, 2023

77

“Under director Lila Neugebauer, ‘Appropriate’ creates one of the most engaging family dynamics presented on stage.”

Harmony
Harmony

Variety · Nov 13, 2023

45

“The play, equal parts glitzy and superficial, consists largely of jaunty songs, written by Manilow, that the group sings on stages — including Carnegie Hall — as they travel the world.”

Jaja's African Hair Braiding

“ ‘Jaja’s African Hair Braiding’ celebrates business owners like Jaja and the ladies who work for her. It’s also a portrait that illustrates everything it takes for Black women, especially immigrants, to survive in this country.”

Just for Us
Just for Us

Variety · Jun 26, 2023

79

“Questions at the show's heart, about the origins and limits of empathy — where we get it from, and to whom we owe it — would benefit from a slight downshift in pace, to lend them greater heft than the brisk clip of laughs.”

Once Upon a One More Time

“Tackling gender roles and power dynamics never sounded as good as it does in 'Once Upon a One More Time,' in which Spears' songs are diligently retro-fitted to the message without sounding jimmied into place.”

Grey House
Grey House

Variety · May 31, 2023

45

“These raw-knuckled riddles are what drive Holloway’s challengingly experimental meditation on the predestination of pain.”

Fat Ham
Fat Ham

Variety · Apr 13, 2023

92

“‘Fat Ham’ is a total gas — the funniest and most invigorating new show on Broadway.”

Shucked
Shucked

Variety · Apr 5, 2023

90

“The funniest and most invigorating new show on Broadway...Winner of the 2022. Pulitzer Prize, ‘Fat Ham’ recasts its source material to imagine what Shakespeare did not how people might overcome circumstances, expectations and their own demons to forge new paths through life.”

Between Riverside and Crazy

“It's a stunning intellectual achievement that's also a total gas, a rare breed of theater deserving of protection at all costs.”

Ain't No Mo'
Ain't No Mo'

Variety · Dec 4, 2022

90

“Explosive as a hand grenade of laughing gas, it’s heady and hysterical and fearlessly provocative.”

& Juliet
& Juliet

Variety · Nov 3, 2022

83

“It's the most fun you'll have in a Broadway theater right now.”

Cost of Living
Cost of Living

Variety · Oct 19, 2022

94

“It's a heart-opening exercise in empathy deftly suited to the form, the kind of theater that imprints on the body and lives in your bones.”

Macbeth
Macbeth

Variety · Apr 28, 2022

25

“Under all the fog (and there is a lot of it), there isn't much substance in this production, which clearly prioritizes an aesthetic and a mood over acting, coherence and Shakespeare's text.”

Funny Girl
Funny Girl

Variety · Apr 25, 2022

46

“What a 2022 audience may find exasperating is the unresolved dichotomy of its leading character.”

Flying Over Sunset
81

“With that cautionary premise in mind, the creatives of this delectable theatrical bonbon treat us to a tasteful trip on the mild side.”

Caroline, or Change

“Sharon D Clarke's towering performance as Caroline anchors this revival, bringing both volcanic power and devastating vulnerability to Kushner's complex character study.”

Thoughts of a Colored Man

“The result attempts an uneven sort of naturalism, as the men posit one purportedly universal truism after another, tracing the outlines of life in place of illuminating its substance.”

SIX
SIX

Variety · Oct 4, 2021

91

“The musical is a clever, catchy and supremely entertaining 80-minute celebration of female empowerment that gives voice to the six wives of Henry VIII.”

Pass Over
Pass Over

Variety · Sep 13, 2021

85

“This playwright's voice can be a joy to hear, and her language is often blistering.”

A Soldier's Play
A Soldier's Play

Variety · Jan 22, 2020

91

“A superb all-male ensemble, under the powerhouse direction of Kenny Leon, attacks this knock-your-socks-off drama with intense emotional passion and intellectual courage.”

Left on Tenth

“Margulies delivers a deeply personal and affecting performance that transforms what could have been a simple memoir adaptation into something genuinely moving.”

Life of Pi

“Every shift back and forward in time allows audiences to be constantly entranced once again by the magical transitions between the worlds, thanks to the magnificent meshing of every single element of the design team.”