Skip to main content
DF

Dave Fargnoli

Reviews

54

Average

70

Highest

89

Lowest

39

81st most prolific critic·1315th most generous scorer· ranks across all reviews
MARKET:
SORT:
The Story
The Story

The Stage · Sep 4, 2026

64

“Though Wilson’s play never quite resolves its meaty themes, it remains a stinging indictment of the US’ media culture.”

Pride
Pride

The Stage · Jun 26, 2026

80

“This frothy musical, with book and lyrics by Stephen Beresford, is heartwarming and dispiritingly necessary.”

The Truth
The Truth

The Stage · Jun 25, 2026

39

“But the truth is, the play is neither funny nor incisive enough to really grip.”

Summerfolk
Summerfolk

The Stage · Mar 18, 2026

63

“Though the sprawling production’s energy flags at times and we never spend quite long enough on any one character, this remains a melancholy, impressionistic portrait of an era – like our own – marked by vacuousness and poised on the brink of sudden upheaval.”

I’m Sorry, Prime Minister

“The play’s pacing is languid and the energy dips during long, static conversations, but Lynn and Gyngell balance out the cerebral dialogue with plenty of sight gags and lightly farcical moments.”

Arcadia
Arcadia

The Stage · Feb 7, 2026

78

“The sparky banter between these two pairs perfectly encapsulates the dramatic tensions that make Stoppard’s writing so compelling.”

Hamlet
Hamlet

The Stage · Oct 3, 2025

40

“Leaning into every opportunity for unsettling humour, but neglecting the rich emotional depth that can make Shakespeare’s tragic masterpiece so powerful, this latest take on the classic tale of delayed revenge is flat, hollow and unfocused.”

The Importance of Being Earnest

“There is a certain cheeky charm to all the clumsy cavorting, but it’s too tame and obvious to feel properly subversive, and the intentionally overblown delivery tends to interrupt the exquisitely poised flow of Wilde’s witty repartee.”

Every Brilliant Thing

“The sweet script achieves a delicate balance between humour, lightness and some more painful recollections.”

The Estate
The Estate

The Stage · Jul 18, 2025

82

“This deliciously vicious satire from Shaan Sahota – in her first fully staged drama – pulls no punches.”

The Fifth Step
The Fifth Step

The Stage · May 20, 2025

82

“The dialogue is sharp and dynamic, full of snappy banter and brutal truths, and the slippery text keeps the audience continually guessing and reassessing the characters’ true motivations.”

The Deep Blue Sea
56

“Telling the story of a destructive affair, Terence Rattigan’s stinging 1952 drama is a sensitively observed classic, underserved by this stiff, overly mannered production.”

Manhunt
Manhunt

The Stage · Apr 9, 2025

84

“This challenging, shattering and strikingly humane play from celebrated writer-director Robert Icke pushes back against such a simplistic assessment, instead using Moat’s grim story to frame potent questions about toxic masculinity.”

Alterations
Alterations

The Stage · Feb 28, 2025

60

“Uneven revival of pioneering Black playwright Michael Abbensetts’ rarely produced 1978 comedy, directed by Lynette Linton and starring Arinzé Kene and Cherrelle Skeete”

Oedipus
Oedipus(2025)

The Stage · Feb 5, 2025

60

“Bursting with bold visuals and angsty, unsubtle performances, this ambitious, often incoherent take on Sophocles’ classic myth puts style firmly ahead of substance.”

A Good House
A Good House

The Stage · Jan 20, 2025

80

“Amy Jephta’s incisive comedy skewers the malignant prejudices simmering within a privileged enclave in South Africa”

Dr Strangelove
Dr Strangelove

The Stage · Oct 30, 2024

78

“This classic Cold War farce feels more timely and more terrifying than ever.”

Oedipus
Oedipus(2024)

The Stage · Oct 16, 2024

83

“The piece has a cumulative power that builds gradually until the atmosphere is riveting, suffocating and unbearably tense.”

Brace Brace
Brace Brace

The Stage · Oct 14, 2024

80

“Anjana Vasan gives an electrifying central performance in this lean, focused and visually arresting drama about PTSD”

Juno and the Paycock

“While there are some hilarious set pieces and some compelling moments of pathos, the production never recovers from its uneven energy and slack pace.”

Giant
Giant

The Stage · Sep 27, 2024

60

“Timely new play interrogates the tarnished legacy of celebrated author Roald Dahl”

G
G

The Stage · Sep 2, 2024

60

“A trio of strong, believable performances provides a core of realism in this surreal, modern-day ghost story”

The Grapes of Wrath

“Although the production feels perhaps overly reverent towards the source material, these powerful, heartfelt performances remain absorbing, channelling the desperation, hope and fury of Steinbeck’s story.”

The Hot Wing King
62

“But the play’s achingly slow pace and contrived conversations keep the drama from generating the compelling heat that it should.”

Echo (Every Cold-Hearted Oxygen)

“This latest piece builds on Soleimanpour’s signature style, but the results are uneven – it is an inelegant collision of earnest philosophising intermingled with metatheatrical commentary on the distance between author, actor and audience.”

Bluets
Bluets

The Stage · May 29, 2024

83

“...it’s a challenging, yet deeply rewarding watch, suffused with wistful beauty.”

Lie Low
Lie Low

The Stage · May 29, 2024

79

“Smyth's dialogue is fantastic, with scenes able to pivot completely”

Instructions for a Teenage Armageddon

“Although the production as a whole can feel non-committal, it is an undeniably truthful piece, which effectively captures the fear, frustration and fizzing potential of the most confusing time of life.”

Dear Octopus
Dear Octopus

The Stage · Feb 15, 2024

82

“Gradually, the play reveals itself as a touching celebration of enduring love, family and forgiveness.”

Stranger Things: The First Shadow

“Based on the phenomenally popular Netflix series, this visually stunning retro-horror romp is audacious, exhilarating and relentlessly inventive...Subtlety is not the goal here, and this show never quite matches the series’ charming mix of nostalgia, hope and horror. But it is an extraordinary, gripping spectacle.”

Lyonesse
Lyonesse

The Stage · Oct 26, 2023

82

“If the symbolism of caged songbirds feels heavy-handed, it is nonetheless well suited to the offbeat, melancholy tone of this thoughtful exploration of the fragility and resilience of hope.”

The Confessions
The Confessions

The Stage · Oct 23, 2023

82

“Zeldin soon demonstrates that her melancholy, thwarted journey towards emancipation makes for a gripping, moving drama.”

Blue Mist
Blue Mist

The Stage · Oct 12, 2023

66

“But while this swirling, muscular movement is visually arresting, it tends to diffuse rather than heighten the building tension.”

Rose
Rose

The Stage · May 30, 2023

56

“But with Rose never rising from the bench where she sits shiva, it can feel profoundly static.”

Dixon and Daughters

“Bruce’s keenly observed dialogue remains vivid and raw, lifted by moments of grim humour.”

Jews – In Their Own Words

“Though the play feels unfocused in places, Freedland’s text is undoubtedly ambitious – trying to tackle historical injustices, fractious party politics and pernicious conspiracy theories simultaneously.”

The Seagull
The Seagull

The Stage · Jul 7, 2022

80

“Fortunately, those performances are uniformly gripping, the character's clashing complications gelling together in a messy but compellingly believable whole.”

Mad House
Mad House

The Stage · Jun 27, 2022

40

“Though it’s loaded with crisp dialogue and moments of wince-inducing viciousness, Rebeck’s script suffers from its low stakes and ponderous pace.”

That Is Not Who I Am

“Their bubbly chemistry and the gentle warmth filling their home always feel extraordinarily fragile within the grim world of the play.”

Two Palestinians go Dogging

“Sami Ibrahim's unrestrained and unwieldy script is cluttered with compelling yet underdeveloped threads, ghostly metaphors, and awkward jokes clustered around a familiar story about the futility of violence.”

The Father and the Assassin

“Epic in scope but grounded in the parallel personal journeys of these two complex figures, The Father and the Assassin successfully weaves a thorny mass of contentious history and factional politics into a tight and accessible drama.”

Middle
Middle

The Stage · May 5, 2022

63

“But with these prosperous, well-adjusted characters grappling with nothing more significant than a dawning sense that they’ve lost control over the trajectory of their lives, the ferociously low stakes rob the piece of any dramatic energy generated by the committed performances it showcases.”

Anna X
Anna X

The Stage · Jul 17, 2021

80

“Anna X is a smart, stylishly told story from former journalist Joseph Charlton.”

Heathers – The Musical

“Christina Bennington is terrifically energetic as protagonist Veronica, skilfully navigating a clumsily written part that positions her as both the show's sardonic narrator and its conflicted emotional heart.”

The Comeback
The Comeback

The Stage · Dec 16, 2020

39

“Director Emily Burns keeps things under tight control, pairing the performer’s snappy repartee with some impeccably daft sight gags.”

Death of England: Delroy

“The play remains admirably, unapologetically angry, a timely articulation of an ongoing struggle for love, dignity and acceptance.”

Faith, Hope and Charity

“The play eloquently distils the galling outrage of a political situation in which, as a society, the most we choose to offer to a starving family is a soggy cheese sandwich.”

The Mousetrap
The Mousetrap

The Stage · Jun 1, 2004

65

“This is a beautifully preserved example of a country house murder mystery, a throwback to theatregoing in the thirties (minus the matinee tea-trays).”

Mnemonic

“...utterly absorbing piece from avant-garde performance makers Complicité”

Dave Fargnoli - Broadway Critic at The Stage | Broadway Scorecard