Skip to main content
JP

Jil Picariello

Reviews

20

Average

73

Highest

96

Lowest

23

163rd most prolific critic·951st most generous scorer
SORT:
Oslo
Oslo

Zeal NYC · Apr 14, 2017

91

And it’s crackling damn good theater too.

The Price
The Price

Zeal NYC · Mar 23, 2017

77

Despite the quibbles (well, more than mere quibbles, to be honest), there’s pure joy in watching such skilled actors take us through the ins and outs of a meaty family psychodrama.

A View From the Bridge

Mark Strong is brilliant as the deluded and denial-ridden Eddie, a hulk of a man living so close to the emotional bone it's nearly impossible to imagine him smiling.

Hamilton
Hamilton

Zeal NYC · Aug 7, 2015

96

I’m so pleased to say it’s even better than I remembered.

Fiddler on the Roof

"Not schmaltzy at all, but rather subdued, perhaps a bit too subdued for all the gusto and verve that 'Fiddler' should offer...This respectful production makes one change: the introduction of a new framing device...But—it’s a big, sad but—there’s something missing.

Fool for Love

Rockwell brings layers of pain and anger and vulnerability to a role that could easily be paper thin in less capable hands.

In Transit

Because every member of the cast is charming, the songs utterly infectious, and every single time they open their mouths to spin their glorious harmonies you completely forget how many times before you've heard all those theatrical tropes.

Indecent

It is enchanting, and wondrous, and painful, and theatrically thrilling.

Junk

The drama is brisk, but chilly, and entertaining…enough.

Marvin's Room

I spent most of the evening wondering why this off-Broadway play was revived in the first place.

Old Times

As you settle into your seat, the revival of Harold Pinter's Old Times envelops you in a sensual haze, a mesmerizing blend of nostalgia and unease that's impossible to resist.

Once on This Island

There is great joy and vitality, which continues from the pre-curtain action right through to the last ravishing moment.

Saint Joan

Her rationality takes a lot of emotional stuffing out of the story, and the series of somewhat disconnected scenes have a strangely becalming effect.

Significant Other

With exceptional performances and a perfect blend of humor and heart, this show will leave you emotional and wanting more – and there's still so much more to uncover in this emotional whirlwind.

Sylvia

It's downright shameful when it happens at a $150-a-ticket Broadway play.

The Children

What is truly marvelous is the gap between the comfortable dialogue between the twosome, and then the threesome, and the emotions snaking around and under them.

The Iceman Cometh

The entire cast, under the energetic direction of Wolfe, simmers and stews, drinks and dreams, brilliantly.