“Happily, the charming new Broadway musical Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York) gets things right.”
Mark Rifkin
Reviews
29
Average
75
Highest
94
Lowest
25
This Week in New York · Jun 13, 2025
“She is in full command of the stage, and her relationship with the audience is almost conversational, as if we are friends with her.”
This Week in New York · Dec 31, 2024
“Eureka Day is the funniest play of the year.”
This Week in New York · Dec 6, 2024
“But just as the Bakkers accepted millions of dollars from their true believers and were busted for fraud, it would be hard to justify spending any of your money on this all-around-disappointing musical.”
This Week in New York · Oct 7, 2024
“In McNeal, however, he takes on too much, straying from the central focus on the future of AI and its impact on literature and humanity itself to include scenes that feel like they’re from another play.”
This Week in New York · Oct 7, 2024
“"The Roommate" is a thoroughly disappointing show despite its two star leads.”
This Week in New York · Jun 6, 2024
“The ninety-minute play concludes with a glorious finale that crosses the finish line with pure genius, reminding us all that there’s no place like home.”
This Week in New York · Apr 4, 2024
“And there is far too much editorializing as the narrative reaches its overly simplistic resolution.”
This Week in New York · Mar 14, 2024
“If this iteration is a hit, it won’t be because of quality, which it is sadly lacking.”
This Week in New York · Mar 7, 2024
“Director Scott Ellis masterfully directs the ninety-minute play, never letting the tension break as the audience wonders whether Father Flynn actually abused Donald.”
This Week in New York · Nov 15, 2023
“You won’t mind spending a lot more time in Jaja’s, moving in for a day or more.”
This Week in New York · Jan 9, 2019
“Butterworth delivered what is currently the best play on Broadway.”
This Week in New York · Dec 17, 2018
““A blistering, explosive play, a searing deep dive into systemic and institutionalized racism in contemporary America...All four actors give dynamic, honest performances, led by Washington...”
This Week in New York · Nov 18, 2018
“Unfortunately, the rest of the show is a hot mess.”
This Week in New York · May 13, 2018
“Daniel Sullivan’s (The Little Foxes, Proof) direction can get a little bumpy though there are several deft touches, and at nearly three hours, the show can be a little trying.”
This Week in New York · Jan 18, 2018
“The Children is the most adult show in New York City right now, a marvelously resonant, intelligent, and engaging play that continually defies expectations as the plot twists and turns while something threatening hangs just past the horizon.”
This Week in New York · Jan 3, 2018
“There’s no stopping the fireball barrage of very funny jokes, both erudite and lowbrow, from Mr. Martin, but Meteor Shower ends up being all punch line, no setup, fizzling out as a Broadway production.”
This Week in New York · Dec 24, 2017
“In many ways Junk is like a Shakespearean history play about war, complete with lies, betrayal, spies, sex, and blood, where words and actions can be twisted to mean something else.”
This Week in New York · Dec 23, 2017
“The Parisian Woman is not without its merits, but it ends up being akin to a good episode of House of Cards, which will not be enough for more discerning theatergoers.”
This Week in New York · Aug 29, 2017
“That’s very likely true, but the eighty-nine-year-old master deserves better than Prince of Broadway.”
This Week in New York · Aug 22, 2017
“Marvin’s Room is a tragicomic story that boldly addresses the question of what happens when a caregiver needs a caregiver as well as a bittersweet reminder of the weight of family responsibility and heartbreaking loss.”
This Week in New York · Jun 11, 2017
“The Little Foxes must go on July 2; don’t miss it.”
This Week in New York · May 23, 2017
“Entrances and exits are the way of life, and the way of theater, and they come together beautifully in this electrifying and masterful production.”
This Week in New York · May 9, 2017
“And everyone wins, especially the audience.”
This Week in New York · May 8, 2017
“It is now having its first Broadway revival, and it’s as sharp and delightful as ever, skewering white liberal guilt, societal racism, and the child-rearing of the wealthy with glee and wit to spare.”
This Week in New York · May 5, 2017
“With all that’s going on in the world today, the play also serves as a warning that this could all happen again if we’re not careful.”
This Week in New York · May 3, 2017
“The new production of Hello, Dolly!, which is breaking house records at the Shubert Theatre, is everything that is wrong with Broadway.”
This Week in New York · Apr 27, 2017
“Rogers’s script melds the comic and the surreal, the serious and the wacky in translating this most unlikely of scenarios into an utterly gripping yet tenderly intimate tale.”
This Week in New York · Apr 10, 2017
“Sweat has transferred exceedingly well from the Public to Broadway, with only very minor tweaks to the script by Nottage (Intimate Apparel, Meet Vera Stark), while the direction by Kate Whoriskey (How I Learned to Drive, The Piano Teacher), who also helmed Nottage’s Ruined, is even sharper.”