Skip to main content
MP

Maryam Philpott

The Reviews HubFreelancer
Are you Maryam Philpott? Add a photo, bio and links to this page.

Also writes for: Cultural Capital, Plays International

Reviews

84

Average

72

Highest

99

Lowest

25

Across all their reviews: less positive than most critics (typical average: 74)Across all their reviews, went against the crowd most on: Burlesque (−36), Dear England (−36)
MARKET:
SORT:
Cloud 9
Cloud 9

The Reviews Hub · Nov 11, 2026

80

“In this lively production, Cooke makes Churchill’s satirical 1979 play feel brand new.”

In line with the show's Critic Score (76)
Tosca - English National Opera

“And that’s the story of this Tosca, a fine idea overpowered by a stalled and bland set design that leaches its power.”

7 points below the show's Critic Score (64)
The Cherry Orchard

“This feeling of a whole community affected by a progress they don't want but perhaps need is the tenure of McPherson's adaptation where emotional suffering is just something you have to do.”

In line with the show's Critic Score (74)
Into the Woods

“Fein has created a production that has magic and drama, danger and hope, and is sinister and illusory all at once.”

11 points above the show's Critic Score (88)
The Standard Of Living

“The Standard of Living has good intentions but doesn’t heed its own final call to ‘act.’”

13 points below the show's Critic Score (70)
The Story
57

“Both the play The Story and reporter Yvonne’s big story suffer from the same issue: a great idea smothered by an overworked device that increasingly becomes a distraction instead of the instrument of the author.”

In line with the show's Critic Score (61)
Allegra
58

“Ultimately, though, it is a sweet show that demands very little from anyone.”

In line with the show's Critic Score (57)
The Misanthrope

“But the play just fizzles out and rather than a story with lots of hinge points, bringing together new information and insights, The Misanthrope becomes a series of conversations that barely hang together...”

20 points below the show's Critic Score (59)
Are You Watching?

“The breadth of perspectives in Dettmer’s play is perhaps far more interesting than the theatrical structure in which they co-exist.”

17 points below the show's Critic Score (72)
War Horse
79

“This is a very technical show with immersive work by Rob Casey as lighting designer and Christopher Shutt on sound, evoking the intensity, fear and drama of life on the front line...”

10 points below the show's Critic Score (89)
1536
1536

The Reviews Hub · May 14, 2026

98

“One of the great joys of theatre is that sometimes you’re in the room when an extraordinary voice breaks through, when something really quite special happens.”

7 points above the show's Critic Score (91)
Summerfolk
48

“So as the characters ponder the purpose of their lives, the audience is left to wonder about the purpose of the play.”

26 points below the show's Critic Score (74)
Marie & Rosetta

“Brant’s story, though, never lives up to these performances, a list of biographical knowledge woven into the dialogue without truly getting beneath the surface of either woman, their hard-won self-belief or the supportive warmth that brought them together.”

15 points below the show's Critic Score (72)
Shadowlands

“This is a revival that understands that Shadowlands is not about tidy faith but about the mess love makes of certainty, and the unpredictable catastrophes that make that mess profoundly, piercingly human.”

13 points above the show's Critic Score (69)
Woman in Mind

“The show never really recovers from its flattened start and uncoordinated approach, feeling long and laboured despite its relatively easy 2-hour and 20-minute running time.”

8 points below the show's Critic Score (65)
The Playboy of the Western World

“All of these versions of the play never quite gel, and for those new to the play, it may be hard to grasp who everyone is and what they want.”

18 points below the show's Critic Score (64)
Paddington The Musical

“If you want two hours of unapologetic, over-the-top, big-hearted theatre that celebrates London, immigration, family, and the sheer joy of spectacle then this Paddington is your friend.”

9 points below the show's Critic Score (89)
Porn Play

“Porn Play is a timely and involving show, with a fine young cast, and an author with fresh, compelling perspectives to offer.”

11 points above the show's Critic Score (71)
End
End

Plays International · Nov 24, 2025

79

“O'Riordan's sensitive, subtle production is the final show programmed by the National's former artistic director Rufus Norris, a mixed reign ending on a high.”

8 points above the show's Critic Score (71)
All My Sons
80

“There’s nothing bigger than family, Chris tells his father, but in trying to secure their future, this family cannot escape the past, and in striving so hard to free themselves from it, van Hove’s absorbing revival only brings a terrible reckoning.”

8 points below the show's Critic Score (88)
Othello

“It can be ravishing on the eye and would be a good introduction for curriculum audiences both as their set text and as a general way in to Shakespeare.”

6 points above the show's Critic Score (70)
Hamlet
36

“‘A hit? A palpable hit?’ No, not in this incarnation and Denmark became a prison for me.”

23 points below the show's Critic Score (59)
Bacchae

“The question is whether the new piece works on its own terms and the answer to that is mixed.”

In line with the show's Critic Score (56)
Punch
Punch

Plays International · Sep 28, 2025

80

“There is no denying the emotional wallop delivered by Penford’s production and the performances at its core.”

In line with the show's Critic Score (80)
Bacchae

“Bacchae arguably doesn’t live up to that accolade with its messy and issues-laden contemporary approach to Euripides’ Greek drama, but with all the power of the National Theatre’s staging team behind it, it is really meaningful that Taleghani’s play is there at all.”

7 points below the show's Critic Score (56)
The Weir
59

“I found the delivery of the stories to be mixed in quality and was not always sure that they always found their mark.”

26 points below the show's Critic Score (85)
Inter Alia

“The format appears a little lazy and rather like playing tennis with the net down.”

9 points below the show's Critic Score (77)
Burlesque
Burlesque

The Reviews Hub · Jul 23, 2025

25

“The show aims to dazzle, but too often Rory Beaton’s concert spotlights just blind the audience as they rotate into your eyes in almost every number in Act Two.”

36 points below the show's Critic Score (61)
The Estate

“Shaan Sahota’s impressive debut play The Estate is an intoxicating cocktail of political satire and family drama, exploring issues of race and patriarchy.”

9 points above the show's Critic Score (69)
The Comedy About Spies

“Mischief take on a fresh genre to parody in The Comedy About Spies that does a good job of combining the company’s classic style of comedy with a heartfelt and intriguing plot, making for an entertaining couple of hours in the theatre.”

In line with the show's Critic Score (84)
Dear England

“I never felt that this play truly found the back of the net, and at two hours 50 minutes was pleased it didn't go to extra time.”

36 points below the show's Critic Score (83)
More Life

“Either there’s a physical disconnect, or incapacity to answer questions. Then Victor and younger sympathetic subordinate Mike (Lewis Mackinnon) discover Bridget (Alison Halstead): she has perfect recall, physical embodiment, and sharp questions. If Bridget succeeds – the whole concept’s loaded – she’ll be first of hundreds of thousands.”

11 points above the show's Critic Score (73)
The Years
The Years

The Reviews Hub · Feb 10, 2025

91

“Transferring from the Almeida Theatre to the Harold Pinter Theatre, Eline Arbo’s stage adaptation of Annie Ernaux’s memoir is hugely affecting and deeply, deeply important.”

8 points above the show's Critic Score (83)
Titanique

“Everyone here is at the top of their game in Tye Blue’s high-energy production with great comedic timing, slick choreography (by Ellenore Scott), and impressions that are immediately recognizable and extremely funny.”

9 points above the show's Critic Score (79)
The Other Place

“Zeldin has the basis of a really interesting family drama and the tensions that emerge from the loss of a family member, but The Other Place feels slight and needs more time to establish the characters and make their desire to be free of their grief more tangible.”

26 points below the show's Critic Score (71)
White Rabbit Red Rabbit

“Here and there, the text betrays its age, asking the actor at one point if they are a ‘boy’ or ‘girl,’ a simplistic gendering that could use an update, while Mohammed clearly wags a disapproving finger when instructed to refer to an audience member as ‘sweetheart.’”

8 points below the show's Critic Score (77)
Hello, Dolly!

“Staunton’s Dolly is a force of nature, running rings around Andy Nyman’s blustering Horace to deliver the star turn that keeps this show on the road.”

16 points below the show's Critic Score (88)
Mnemonic
79

“And it is clear that a quarter of a century on, no one builds a technical and cinematic story quite like Complicité.”

In line with the show's Critic Score (80)
Next to Normal

“Next to Normal has deep emotional resonance, wells of empathy that will grip you in individual scenes but it also has a notable cumulative effect.”

In line with the show's Critic Score (79)
The Bounds

“The Bounds is new writing of the highest quality.”

28 points above the show's Critic Score (63)
Boys from the Blackstuff

“Alan Bleasdale’s Boys from the Blackstuff is poetic and tragic, celebratory and honest about the state-of-the-nation forces that have been shaping ordinary lives in the last 40 years and just how much it still hurts.”

17 points above the show's Critic Score (74)
Dugsi Dayz
74

“Sharp lines and strong characterisation overwhelm a slightly stagnant story, but Ali keeps the audience laughing.”

In line with the show's Critic Score (74)
London Tide

“The play is fitfully moving, notably in its discussion of social mobility, and much of the acting is first-rate.”

In line with the show's Critic Score (63)
Underdog: The Other Other Bronte

“Underdog: The Other Other Brontë is the most riotous retelling of literary myth, punching so fast it shortens its estimated two hours 15 by about eight minutes.”

10 points above the show's Critic Score (68)
Opening Night

“Opening Night and its lead take you through a performance like no other.”

30 points above the show's Critic Score (48)
Dear Octopus
88

“Smith’s play is just as gripping and evocative as Steel’s, understanding the restrictions and minutiae of women’s lives, their spans of control and the intimate relationship between siblings that long absences can never entirely sever.”

10 points above the show's Critic Score (78)
The Witches

“The team behind The Witches have found the heart as well as the art of making a show that is properly scary, but also properly delightful, in equal measure, to fill the Christmas platter full to bursting on the Olivier stage.”

In line with the show's Critic Score (83)
The Witches

“Using Dahl’s architecture, Kirkwood and Malloy have written a very witty and incredibly entertaining show, blending the silly with the scary to excellent effect and giving most of the key characters just enough substance to explain their behaviours.”

In line with the show's Critic Score (83)
King Lear

“I’m sorry – this production does not rise above Base Camp and possibly does not even get its hiking boots on.”

11 points below the show's Critic Score (47)
Lyonesse
Lyonesse

The Reviews Hub · Oct 27, 2023

44

“Lyonesse has the nub of a really great story, a woman taking centre stage to finally speak about a famous, toxic man who essentially took her life and career away.”

In line with the show's Critic Score (49)
The Confessions

“At its best, the play has Older Alice reflect on missed opportunities in the poignant manner with which Beckett characters look back at the midnight of their youth.”

15 points below the show's Critic Score (75)
Death of England: Closing Time

“Clint Dyer (who also directs) and Roy Williams have constructed an electrifying and fulfilling final chapter with all the bitterness of tricky in-law (or in-sin, as described here) connections and also respect between two women who will barely admit it.”

14 points above the show's Critic Score (77)
Pygmalion

“This fresh production transformed to a different era has been mined for possible anachronisms which have been skilfully removed.”

24 points above the show's Critic Score (67)
Dixon and Daughters

“The play is less successful at managing the overall contrasts been comedy and its darker themes...”

In line with the show's Critic Score (73)
Black Superhero

“BLACK SUPERHERO is a consistently entertaining if scattered reflection on friendship, love, family and queer identities that is often very funny but sometimes loses its central thread.”

14 points above the show's Critic Score (61)
Oklahoma!
91

“Oklahoma! is sensational of course; it was brilliant in the round at the Young Vic and it is just as as horribly, wonderfully, magnetically compelling at the Wyndham’s.”

17 points above the show's Critic Score (74)
Romeo and Julie

“Romeo and Julie is a pleasant but conventionally plotted reflection on working class aspiration, family and love across a divide.”

14 points below the show's Critic Score (76)
Orlando
Orlando

The Reviews Hub · Dec 6, 2022

71

“Emma Corrin is fortunately a charismatic stage presence, suggesting the slightly swaggering masculinity of the young Orlando and the confident female sexuality of the elder, connecting the two together in one consistent character with Corrin as watchable as ever.”

6 points below the show's Critic Score (77)
The Crucible

“The final reconciliation scene in prison with his wife Elizabeth – an impressive performance from Eileen Walsh – is genuinely moving.”

In line with the show's Critic Score (80)
The Crucible

“Turner’s vision of The Crucible is bleak but hugely rewarding, digging deep into the violent paranoia and creating a convincing blood lust dressed up as justice that grips Salem.”

In line with the show's Critic Score (80)
Cruise
Cruise

The Reviews Hub · Aug 18, 2022

93

“Holden has written one of the great plays of the last year so don’t miss this second chance to go cruising.”

In line with the show's Critic Score (91)
All of Us
77

“Francesca Martinez’s latest play All of Us in the Dorfman is a ferocious statement about living with a disability and the deliberate erosion of independence that dehumanising government social care and economic policies have created.”

11 points above the show's Critic Score (66)
Much Ado About Nothing

“Godwin’s feelgood show is stylish, escapist entertainment with high production values that doesn’t quite hit the romantic or comedic sweet spots.”

In line with the show's Critic Score (70)
Middle
Middle

The Reviews Hub · May 5, 2022

63

“Middle is appropriately middling.”

In line with the show's Critic Score (68)
Prima Facie
94

“Comer’s performance is just so wonderful, capturing the comedic tones in the early scenes presenting the cocky, all-conquering female barrister who is a little too comfortable in herself and what she does.”

13 points above the show's Critic Score (81)
Bonnie and Clyde

“This is a production that does much to restore the show’s reputation.”

18 points above the show's Critic Score (61)
Our Generation

“Blythe has made us care about these people, slowly using this anthology of scenes to create audience investment in them and their lives with comedy often the entry point for recognition, understanding and empathy.”

8 points above the show's Critic Score (69)
Manor
Manor

The Reviews Hub · Nov 24, 2021

43

“This muddled drama doesn’t know where to pitch itself as it tries to be all things to all people in a multistranded approach that can’t quite bring together its themes of class, history and identity politics.”

In line with the show's Critic Score (40)
Rare Earth Mettle

“Smith’s play, running at over three hours, never feels it; instead, it is sprightly and often very witty as it dashes between these four perspectives as the players all try to outsmart and double-cross each other.”

29 points above the show's Critic Score (49)
The Last Five Years

“Lynch and Higginson together are sensational, better even than they were at the Southwark Playhouse, and it’s impossible to imagine two greater performances in the West End right now.”

16 points above the show's Critic Score (76)
Paradise

“The audience applause breaks between these monologues are a bit much, but Sharp's delivery and Tempest's writing are both sublime.”

In line with the show's Critic Score (69)
Jersey Boys
85

“It is an extraordinary West End debut that adds an extra pizazz to an old warhorse retuning to central London in this refreshed production.”

10 points above the show's Critic Score (75)
After Life
85

“After Life is certainly worthwhile and ensures that the National Theatre’s return is a memorable one.”

9 points above the show's Critic Score (76)
Walden
59

“It’s an ambitious endeavour that matches in spirit Friedman’s own effort with the season. However, despite a handsome physical production. a bevy of ideas, and some familiar names on the stage and behind the scenes, the production proves to be talky and static in equal measure.”

In line with the show's Critic Score (63)
Master Harold and the Boys

“Roy Alexander Weise’s wonderfully subtle production brings out the tenderness between characters as well as the underlying tensions.”

11 points above the show's Critic Score (76)
Woyzeck
41

“It is even more surprising when a play written in the early nineteenth century seems more modern and avant-garde than this production’s updated twenty-first century adaptation.”

28 points below the show's Critic Score (69)