Skip to main content
S

Scribicide

Tier 3

Reviews

33

Average

72

Highest

92

Lowest

36

99th most prolific outlet·408th most generous scorer·1 different critic
SORT:
King Lear
King Lear

Aaron Botwick · May 15, 2019

56

"The dominant color in Lear's court is gold; a porcelain bulldog and lion straddle the throne. These choices, with their whiff of Art Deco, are no doubt topical, though never fully explored: the text, about the dissolution of ancient Britain, doesn't really speak to our current political moment, and that's okay.

Ink
Ink

Aaron Botwick · May 3, 2019

66

The result is an unilluminating albeit entertaining mash-up of docudrama and Richard III.

Hadestown
Hadestown

Aaron Botwick · Apr 25, 2019

91

'Hadestown' is the best new musical I have seen in years...overflowing with rich, lively music.

Burn This
Burn This

Aaron Botwick · Apr 23, 2019

44

Despite its adoration by acting students, Wilson’s play is nothing special.

Oklahoma!
Oklahoma!

Aaron Botwick · Apr 17, 2019

87

Like the show as a whole, the dance demonstrates that there is much we can do to revivify these staid mid-century classics.

Kiss Me, Kate
88

The result is more even-handed, less humiliating, and vaudevillian—and what remains is a fully enjoyable comedy of manners in the style of Noël Coward.

Choir Boy
Choir Boy

Aaron Botwick · Jan 19, 2019

78

Gay or straight, these kids are all deprived of love, of nurture, mimicking a manhood they have not yet reached and lashing as a cover for vulnerability; stern-faced Bobby usually looks like he is moments away from either punching or crying.

Network
Network

Aaron Botwick · Dec 16, 2018

39

Cluttered with schtick and flashy gadgets, this Network makes lots of noise but has little resonance.

The Waverly Gallery

Ultimately, it is the harmony created between these first-rate actors, all extraordinarily generous to one another, that makes The Waverly Gallery essential viewing.

The Ferryman
74

As melodrama, then, The Ferryman is crackerjack theater, riveting for most of its three-hour-plus runtime.

The Nap
The Nap

Aaron Botwick · Sep 29, 2018

36

This story of the World Snooker Championship in Sheffield is just dull, a non-entity, a play that was written on autopilot.

The Children
75

Ms. Kirkwood’s dialogue is sharp, funny, and somewhat spare, preferring suggestion over exposition.

The Parisian Woman

The material is far too thin to justify its existence: why bother with Trump at all, why not just write a traditional thriller when you have so little to say?

Junk
Junk

Aaron Botwick · Nov 27, 2017

88

Mr. Akhtar masterfully weaves together a collection of journalists, lawyers, businessmen, and traders to create a portrait of American wealth that is compelling, illuminating, and relevant all at once.

Marvin's Room

The cast assembled here, for the play's first Broadway production, is first-rate across the board.

Indecent
Indecent

Aaron Botwick · May 14, 2017

75

It’s a shame that a play like Indecent—a play that is often vital and brimming with life—succumbs in its final scenes to kitsch.

Oslo
Oslo

Aaron Botwick · Apr 18, 2017

87

This is docudrama of the first caliber, in which a large cast and even larger issues are expertly condensed into almost three hours of thrilling drama.

Present Laughter

For the life of me, I cannot see why, and Present Laughter serves as a delightful rebuke to this trend, proving that there’s always more room for madcap farce on the Great White Way.

Sweat
Sweat

Aaron Botwick · Mar 26, 2017

84

Sweat is an indictment of an economic system that is unconcerned with company loyalty or with rewarding decades of literally back-breaking work.

Miss Saigon
Miss Saigon

Aaron Botwick · Mar 23, 2017

45

Miss Saigon uses spectacle to manufacture tragedy, forgetting the human element along the way.

Heisenberg
Heisenberg

Aaron Botwick · Oct 13, 2016

69

Simon Stephens’ Heisenberg, likely named after the uncertain relationship in which these two find themselves, is a gentle and unassuming play, one whose eighty minutes pass without much surprise but without much to dissatisfy, either.

Eclipsed
Eclipsed

Aaron Botwick · Apr 29, 2016

88

Eclipsed is precisely the kind of work that precludes this reaction, forcing a confrontation between audience and subject matter without offering the easy pressure relief valve of cynical hopelessness or self-congratulatory liberalism.

Fiddler on the Roof

“Broadway musicals are so often disappointing because they don’t really believe in the value of their silliness. In other words, they hedge their bets...

Fun Home
Fun Home

Aaron Botwick · Apr 29, 2015

49

There’s nothing really wrong with that, I suppose, but, like the fun house mirror, what I know to be a funny, moving, and endlessly smart story is reflected back at me as fairly average Broadway fare.

Something Rotten!

Something Rotten! is that rare piece of fluff that knows exactly where it stands while occasionally betraying an unexpected intelligence.