Skip to main content

The Forward

Tier 4: Independent blog. Counts 20% as much as a Tier 1 review.

Reviews

12

Average

76

Highest

89

Lowest

44

178th most prolific outlet·355th most generous scorer·5 different critics
SORT:
Giant
Giant

PJ Grisar · Mar 24, 2026

77

“Director Nicholas Hytner has staged a boxing match for today's discourse, without changing a line from a pre-Oct. 7 script.”

Operation Mincemeat

“With jazzy ear-worms and a poignant showstopper in which MI5 secretary Hester Legatt (Jak Malone) dictates a letter to the agency's fictive serviceman, Mincemeat is supremely entertaining.”

Redwood
80

“You wouldn’t expect it, but this play about grief, healing and California redwoods just might be the most Jewish — and most original — show on Broadway this season.”

Three Houses
78

“For anyone who has not previously been initiated into Malloy’s work and longs for the kind of musical that transcends banal commerciality, Three Houses is a must-see simply for the opportunity to marvel at the vastness of its creator’s byzantine brain.”

Cabaret at the Kit Kat Club

“The triumph of this iteration is how it anticipates its audience, teasing them with frothy liberation before making them gasp at Nazi armbands and shattered windows.”

Harry Potter and the Cursed Child

“Underneath all of the whimsy, cuteness, and nostalgia, this play is dark...Filled with action, humor, and adventure. The magic of the wizarding world is conveyed by a truly amazing combination of choreography, set design, and old-fashioned magic tricks...Not everything is perfect...”

Indecent
Indecent

Jesse Oxfeld · Apr 19, 2017

89

“It's not the only haunting moment in this beautifully staged production.”

The Heidi Chronicles

“It opened last night in revival at the Music Box, and, two and a half decades later, it’s still fantastic — searching, thought-provoking, very funny, and more than a little bit sad.”

The Forward - Theatre Reviews (Tier 4) | Broadway Scorecard