Skip to main content
PH

Pete Hempstead

Reviews

28

Average

74

Highest

95

Lowest

42

132nd most prolific critic·1238th most generous scorer· ranks across all reviews
MARKET:
SORT:
Dog Day Afternoon

“Now, this ultimately tragic story of two desperate bunglers comes off as a sitcom with almost zero dramatic tension or suspense.”

Oedipus
Oedipus

TheaterMania · Nov 13, 2025

87

“Manville towers above the stage in an unforgettable turn.”

Stranger Things: The First Shadow

“The First Shadow, now an integral part of the ST canon, is an absolute must-see for all enthusiasts, and it will certainly inspire some of the uninitiated to binge the original (mission accomplished, Netflix).”

Boop! The Musical

“With a zippy score, terrific tap numbers choreographed by director Jerry Mitchell, energetic performances from a top-notch cast, and a plot that doesn’t tax your brain, Boop! is one of the feel-good musicals of the year.”

Redwood
Redwood

TheaterMania · Feb 13, 2025

66

“But the show itself hangs from a story that’s as thin as a reed, making for a sometimes-lumbering musical that tends to sag under the weight of its nearly two-hour runtime.”

All In: Comedy About Love

“All In feels like a joke that goes on for too long and it doesn’t have the knee-slapping payoff to make it worth 90 minutes of your time.”

Eureka Day
Eureka Day

TheaterMania · Dec 16, 2024

75

“Eureka Day is actually a blunt yet effective portrait of power in allegedly egalitarian spaces.”

Our Town
Our Town

TheaterMania · Oct 11, 2024

81

“This feels a lot more like our town than Our Town ever has.”

The Cottage
The Cottage

TheaterMania · Jul 25, 2023

88

“The Cottage more than fits that bill. It’s no real surprise that it works as well as it does. Director Jason Alexander (Seinfeld) knows how to do smart yet silly comedy without overdoing it, and The Cottage is a play that needs only light touches to make it frothy and effervescent.”

Fat Ham
Fat Ham

TheaterMania · Apr 12, 2023

66

“Funny and thought-provoking as it is, Fat Ham feels like the second-to-last draft of something better.”

Shucked
Shucked

TheaterMania · Apr 4, 2023

78

“Even if you’re not in the mood for some feel-good sentiment, as a laugh-out-loud crowd-pleaser, ‘Shucked’ is a shucking good time.”

Bob Fosse's Dancin'

“This new incarnation feels like an advanced class in Fosse in which all the students have learned how the pronounce well enough for us to understand but they still have a heavy accent.”

Ain't No Mo'
79

“It's an ingenious way to dig into some of the nasty truths about this country's equally absurd failure to come to terms with the legacy of slavery.”

A Christmas Carol

“This Christmas Carol will send you out into the cold feeling warm, reflective, and maybe — maybe — just a little less cynical about the state of the world right now.”

The Little Prince

“High-flying theatrics and feats of agility would seem like an inspired way to tell the Little Prince's tale of planet-hopping and self-discovery, but unfortunately this production fails to capture the imagination the way the book does, and for the most part it underwhelms.”

Take Me Out
79

“Ferguson looks like he's having a lot of fun playing him, and his performance translates into a great time at the theater — something we could all use right now.”

Burn This
Burn This

TheaterMania · Apr 16, 2019

45

“It would have been better if Burn This had been left to flicker out there too.”

John Lithgow: Stories By Heart

“Despite Lithgow's acting prowess and the nostalgic appeal that Stories by Heart promises, director Daniel Sullivan hasn't whipped things up enough to make the show into engaging theater.”

Marvin's Room
71

“It's unfortunate that more of the play's humor doesn't come through in Roundabout Theatre Company's production. Director Anne Kauffman paints this small, intensely intimate family drama with broad strokes that sometimes obscure the comic moments that lighten the darkness...”

Indecent
Indecent

TheaterMania · Apr 18, 2017

92

“Under Rebecca Taichman's confident and inspired direction, Indecent has been polished to a lustrous shine for this staging, with an achingly poetic majesty that makes it one of the season's unique and essential Broadway events.”

Pete Hempstead - Broadway Critic at TheaterMania | Broadway Scorecard