All Gold Lists
Off-Broadway Critical Gold List™
The highest-rated Off-Broadway shows by professional critics(In Progress)
10 shows | 2026-2027 Season
1
Spellbound
PLAYREVIVALCLOSED
Closed Sep 2026 · Opened Aug 2026
Critical Gold
90
2
La Bohème
OPERAREVIVALNOW PLAYING
Closes Apr 2027 · Opened Sep 2026
Critical Gold
88
3
Hershey Felder: The Piano and Me
PLAYORIGINALCLOSED
Closed Aug 2026 · Opened Jul 2026
Critical Gold
88
Crazy Mama: A True Story of Love and Madness
PLAYORIGINALCLOSED
Closed Oct 2026 · Opened Sep 2026
Critical Gold
88
Benevolent
PLAYORIGINALCLOSED
Closed Sep 2026 · Opened Aug 2026
Critical Gold
84
School Pictures
MUSICALREVIVALNOW PLAYING
Closes Nov 2026 · Opened Oct 2026
Critical Gold
84
I Became We
PLAYORIGINALNOW PLAYING
Closes Nov 2026 · Opened Oct 2026
Critical Gold
84
Hospital Hour
PLAYORIGINALNOW PLAYING
Closes Nov 2026 · Opened Oct 2026
Critical Gold
84
Queeney Todd: The Demon Bottom of Fleet Street
MUSICALORIGINALCLOSED
Closed Oct 2026 · Opened Oct 2026
Critical Gold
83
Tristan & Yseult
MUSICALORIGINALNOW PLAYING
Closes Nov 2026 · Opened Nov 2026
Critical Gold
83