Skip to main content
All Gold Lists

West End Critical Gold List™

The highest-rated West End shows by professional critics

25 shows across all seasons | All-Time

All-Time
1
Cyrano De Bergerac play

Cyrano De Bergerac

PLAYORIGINALCLOSED

Closed Mar 2022 · Opened Feb 2022 · 2021-2022

Critical Gold
94
2
Gypsy musical

Gypsy

MUSICALORIGINALCLOSED

Closed Nov 2015 · Opened Apr 2015 · 2014-2015

Critical Gold
93
3
Summer and Smoke play

Summer and Smoke

PLAYORIGINALCLOSED

Closed Jan 2019 · Opened Nov 2018 · 2018-2019

Critical Gold
93
4
Jerusalem play

Jerusalem

PLAYORIGINALCLOSED

Closed Aug 2022 · Opened Apr 2022 · 2021-2022

Critical Gold
93
5
Follies musical

Follies

MUSICALORIGINALCLOSED

Closed May 2019 · Opened Feb 2019 · 2018-2019

Critical Gold
92
6
Cruise play

Cruise

PLAYORIGINALCLOSED

Closed Sep 2022 · Opened Aug 2022 · 2022-2023

Critical Gold
91
7
Matilda The Musical musical

Matilda The Musical

MUSICALORIGINALNOW PLAYING

Opened Nov 2011 · 2011-2012

Critical Gold
91
8
The Ferryman play

The Ferryman

PLAYORIGINALCLOSED

Closed May 2017 · Opened May 2017 · 2016-2017

Critical Gold
91
9
The Lehman Trilogy play

The Lehman Trilogy

PLAYORIGINALCLOSED

Closed Jan 2025 · Opened Oct 2024 · 2024-2025

Critical Gold
91
10
1536 play

1536

PLAYORIGINALCLOSED

Closed Aug 2026 · Opened May 2026 · 2025-2026

Critical Gold
91
11
Crazy for You musical

Crazy for You

MUSICALORIGINALCLOSED

Closed Dec 2023 · Opened Jul 2023 · 2023-2024

Critical Gold
91
12
Hamilton musical

Hamilton

MUSICALORIGINALNOW PLAYING

Opened Dec 2017 · 2017-2018

Critical Gold
90
13
Follies musical

Follies

MUSICALORIGINALCLOSED

Closed Jan 2018 · Opened Sep 2017 · 2017-2018

Critical Gold
90
14
Cyrano de Bergerac play

Cyrano de Bergerac

PLAYREVIVALCLOSED

Closed Sep 2026 · Opened Jun 2026 · 2025-2026

Critical Gold
90
15
Groundhog Day musical

Groundhog Day

MUSICALORIGINALCLOSED

Closed Aug 2023 · Opened Jun 2023 · 2022-2023

Critical Gold
89
16
Small Island play

Small Island

PLAYORIGINALCLOSED

Closed Apr 2022 · Opened Mar 2022 · 2021-2022

Critical Gold
89
17
Dear England play

Dear England

PLAYORIGINALCLOSED

Closed Jan 2024 · Opened Oct 2023 · 2023-2024

Critical Gold
89
18
Operation Mincemeat musical

Operation Mincemeat

MUSICALORIGINALNOW PLAYING

Opened May 2023 · 2022-2023

Critical Gold
89
19
People, Places and Things play

People, Places and Things

PLAYORIGINALCLOSED

Closed Aug 2024 · Opened May 2024 · 2023-2024

Critical Gold
89
20
War Horse play

War Horse

PLAYORIGINALCLOSED

Closed Jul 2026 · Opened Jun 2026 · 2025-2026

Critical Gold
89
21
Death of a Salesman play

Death of a Salesman

PLAYORIGINALCLOSED

Closed Jan 2020 · Opened Nov 2019 · 2019-2020

Critical Gold
89
22
Ballet Shoes play

Ballet Shoes

PLAYORIGINALCLOSED

Closed Feb 2026 · Opened Nov 2025 · 2025-2026

Critical Gold
89
23
The Master Builder play

The Master Builder

PLAYORIGINALCLOSED

Closed Mar 2016 · Opened Jan 2016 · 2015-2016

Critical Gold
89
24
Into the Woods musical

Into the Woods

MUSICALREVIVALNOW PLAYING

Opened Oct 2026 · 2026-2027

Critical Gold
89
25
Paddington The Musical musical

Paddington The Musical

MUSICALORIGINALNOW PLAYING

Opened Nov 2025 · 2025-2026

Critical Gold
89

Methodology: 5+ scored reviews. Minimum criticscore: 73. Top 25 across all seasons since 2005.