| 1 | | | Sweeper | NYDCC Winner | 5 Wins · 8 Noms |
| 2 | | | Decorated | NYDCC Winner | 4 Wins · 6 Noms |
| 3 | | | Decorated | 4 Tony Wins | 4 Wins · 13 Noms |
| 4 | | | Decorated | Tony · Best Lighting Design of … | 2 Wins · 8 Noms |
| 5 | | | Decorated | Tony · Best Direction | 2 Wins · 6 Noms |
| 6 | | | Decorated | Pulitzer Drama | 0 Wins · 2 Noms |
| 7 | | | Decorated | Tony · Best Revival (Play) | 1 Win · 3 Noms |
| 8 | | | Decorated | Pulitzer Drama | 0 Wins · 5 Noms |
| 9 | | | Honored | Tony · Lead Performance | 1 Win · 4 Noms |
| 10 | | | Honored | Tony · Featured Performance | 1 Win · 9 Noms |
| 11 | | | Honored | 3 Tony Wins | 3 Wins · 5 Noms |
| 12 | | | Honored | Pulitzer Drama | 0 Wins · 5 Noms |
| 13 | | | Honored | — | 0 Wins · 9 Noms |
| 14 | | | Honored | — | 0 Wins · 6 Noms |
| 15 | | | Honored | Tony · Best Scenic Design of a … | 1 Win · 9 Noms |
| 16 | | | Honored | Pulitzer Finalist | 0 Wins · 2 Noms |
| 17 | | | Honored | Tony · Lead Performance | 1 Win · 3 Noms |
| 18 | | | Honored | — | 0 Wins · 6 Noms |
| 19 | | | Honored | Tony · Featured Performance | 1 Win · 2 Noms |
| 20 | | | Honored | — | 0 Wins · 2 Noms |
| 21 | | | Honored | — | 0 Wins · 1 Nom |
| 22 | | | Honored | — | 0 Wins · 6 Noms |
| 23 | | | Nominated | — | 0 Wins · 5 Noms |
| 24 | | | Honored | — | 0 Wins · 1 Nom |
| 25 | | | Nominated | — | 0 Wins · 4 Noms |
| 26 | | | Nominated | — | 0 Wins · 1 Nom |
| 27 | | | Nominated | — | 0 Wins · 1 Nom |
| 28 | | | Nominated | — | 0 Wins · 3 Noms |
| 29 | | | Nominated | — | 0 Wins · 1 Nom |
| 30 | | | Nominated | — | — |
| 31 | | | Nominated | — | — |
| 32 | | | Nominated | — | 0 Wins · 2 Noms |
| 33 | | | Nominated | — | — |
| 34 | | | Nominated | — | — |
| 35 | | | Nominated | — | — |
| 36 | | | Nominated | — | — |