Skip to main content
A Beautiful Noise, The Neil Diamond Musical Broadway musical poster
MUSICALCLOSED

A Beautiful Noise, The Neil Diamond Musical

Broadhurst Theatre

Opened Dec 4, 2022 · Closed Jun 30, 2024 · Ran for 1 year, 6 months

Critics' Take

Critics find this jukebox biomusical formulaic and tonally uneven, though Will Swenson's performance and Diamond's hit catalog delight devoted fans who'll sing along to "Sweet Caroline."

This show has closed. Tickets are no longer available.

Critic Scorecard

30 reviews
Sort:
Counts
  • Tier 1: 100%
  • Tier 2: 75%
  • Tier 3: 40%
  • Tier 4: 20%
New York Daily News logo
New York Daily News

“Diamond was a kind of talisman, and his music, filled with his signature blend of macho groan and sweet melodiousness, is complex enough to stand a show like this.” By Chris Jones, Dec 4, 2022

The New York Sun logo
The New York Sun

“'A Beautiful Noise' manages to fly on the strength of the collective talent behind it, not least of all Mr. Diamond's.” By Elysa Gardner, Dec 5, 2022

Theater Pizzazz logo
Theater Pizzazz

“For Diamond fans A Beautiful Noise is a love letter and a bounteous gift of musical exultation, with enough juice to welcome a non-boomer audience into the cult of Diamond.” By Marilyn Lester, Dec 5, 2022

Variety logo
Variety

“That fits him, and his musical of the same name, like a hand in a glove.” By A.D. Amorosi, Dec 5, 2022

How this score works →