Skip to main content
HM

Howard Miller

Also writes for: Upstage Downstage

Reviews

164

Average

75

Highest

95

Lowest

25

27th most prolific critic·854th most generous scorer· ranks across all reviews
MARKET:
SORT:
Beaches, A New Musical

Unfortunately, the early scenes featuring the youngsters (Samantha Schwartz as the smartass Little Cee Cee and Zeya Grace as the genteel Little Bertie) lack credibility or charm, a problem that largely runs through the entire production.

The Balusters

Brava and bravo all around for making this social satire an entertaining and often very funny night on the town, especially when we can hide in the audience and watch the fireworks (ranging from sparklers to aerial rockets) going off from a safe distance.

Schmigadoon!

It belongs on the stage, free from the confines and two-dimensionality of the small screen.

Fallen Angels

That's Fallen Angels, an evening of good silly fun, skillfully directed and performed by a cast that is both solid in their delivery and comfortable enough to take on a loosey-goosey style, speak in catch-as-catch-can British accents, and even make each other laugh.

Proof
Proof

Talkin' Broadway · Apr 16, 2026

95

An altogether first-class production that speaks to the brain and the heart in equal measure, a winner in every way.

The Fear of 13

That may be enough, but I would argue that this dramatic retelling would be better served if it were to provide more of the complexity of the case, or even some well-structured fictionalized embellishment.

Titanique
64

And I'd be remiss if I did not reiterate that the cast, as well as the design elements, definitely rises above the low-brow material.

Bug
Bug

Talkin' Broadway · Jan 11, 2026

81

That is a truth that rings throughout the production, and it includes those of us in the audience as well.

Marjorie Prime

Certainly that is something to ponder during the play's final scene, which may be intended as a grace note of irony but which, in retrospect, does not seem ironic at all as we wade into the unknown waters of a brave new world.

Chess
Chess

Talkin' Broadway · Nov 16, 2025

49

But, really, a good pair of headphones and a recording will serve you just as well.

Oedipus
Oedipus

Talkin' Broadway · Nov 13, 2025

91

Icke's adaptation is an absolute model of Hitchcockian suspense, and the performances could not be better.

The Queen of Versailles

The insurmountable problem with The Queen of Versailles is that we are given no reason to care one way or the other about this spendthrift family, not even when they nearly lose their property during the 2008 financial crisis.

Little Bear Ridge Road

That plus a beautiful blend of gifted actors and director, a surprising amount of genuinely laugh-inducing humor, and even a soupçon of hope make for a thoroughly engaging 95 minutes, during which we find ourselves rooting for those we might otherwise want little to do with.

Art
Art

Talkin' Broadway · Sep 16, 2025

87

Throughout, all three actors deliver the goods with a perfect pacing and interactions that make this a thoroughly engaging production of a whip-smart play that easily makes Art a delightful and thought-provoking objet d'art for our time.

Mamma Mia!
78

While not exactly a sophisticated evening of Sondheim, this is a show that clearly knows what it is, having been kept under the watchful eye of director Phyllida Lloyd since its inception.

Call Me Izzy

Thanks to Jean Smart's convincing grasp of her character, Call Me Izzy soars above its seeming movie-of-the-week roots to leave us something new to ponder about cruelty, kindness, and human endurance.

John Proctor is the Villain

John Proctor Is the Villain is truly a most engaging play, with a terrific ensemble cast that makes even discussions about The Crucible thoroughly engrossing.

Glengarry Glen Ross

That's what's missing, the requisite team play that would prepare the field so one or more of the otherwise excellent actors might hit one out of the park instead of merely participating in a game of catch.

Purpose
Purpose

Talkin' Broadway · Mar 17, 2025

88

Act I of Purpose is sheer perfection, exquisitely and seamlessly played out in dark and darkly comic moments.

Redwood
Redwood

Talkin' Broadway · Feb 13, 2025

67

Despite any sympathy we might have for Jesse, she is not all that interesting a character.

English
English

Talkin' Broadway · Jan 23, 2025

72

Because the performances are so strong, the cast members are able to mine English for every nuance of humor and individuality that is available to them.

Gypsy
Gypsy

Talkin' Broadway · Dec 19, 2024

78

Audra McDonald sinks her teeth into the role of Rose like no other

Eureka Day
78

David Bengali's projections of the community's on-line discussion are a priceless addition.

Cult of Love

As dysfunctional family plays go, Cult of Love is richly rewarding and enormously entertaining, thanks to an exceptionally fine ensemble of actors, Headland's spot-on dialog, and Trip Cullman's brilliant direction that make this one stand out from others of this ilk.

Swept Away
85

Swept Away is an original and adventurous foray along the darker edges of what musical theatre can accomplish.

Elf
Elf

Talkin' Broadway · Nov 17, 2024

85

Go, and I can pretty much guarantee you will have yourself a grand "sparklejollytwinklejingley" time.

Maybe Happy Ending

The show was a big hit in South Korea, where it originated; word-of-mouth and the wonders of social media may well do the trick here.

Our Town
Our Town

Talkin' Broadway · Oct 10, 2024

64

A bigger one lies in Kenny Leon's decision to bring in a contemporary perspective that is in conflict with the underlying "truth" of the place and time in which Our Town takes place.

Home
Home

Talkin' Broadway · Jun 5, 2024

88

Home, directed in a most unassuming, unfussy way by Kenny Leon, is the most uplifting play to hit Broadway in a very long time.

Mother Play
75

It is Lange who stands at the center, giving a performance that throughout is full of nuance as she portrays this complicated mess of a woman.

The Who's Tommy

For anyone else, it will be quite the theatrical experience, a rock opera that truly earns its reputation as the genuine article.

Water for Elephants

By any measure, Water for Elephants is a spectacular display of theatrical collaboration at its best, and it should have wide appeal to kinkers and rubes alike.

An Enemy of the People

By stripping it of some of its complexity, the play resonates for our time while, with the match-off between its stars, the production itself gives us two exciting performances at its core.

Prayer for the French Republic

You will not soon forget these characters or the difficult decision they face as they struggle with what is yet another piece of the endlessly complex immigrants' story.

Appropriate
84

Appropriate frequently stretches the limits of what it means to be "over the top," but the portrait it paints of human frailty and corruption is as ancient and complex as they come.

How to Dance in Ohio

But it is unclear as to the intent of the show, which lacks much by way of character development, dramatic tension, or insight.

Harmony
Harmony

Talkin' Broadway · Nov 13, 2023

86

Harmony is an altogether original and serious work that beautifully marries the story of the Comedian Harmonists with that of the years of their rise and fall.

I Need That

But because the plot consists of a conglomeration of barely examined ideas, the whole fails to satisfy beyond the comedic stylings of Danny DeVito.

The Shark Is Broken

I hate to carp, but while Jaws may be the ultimate fish story, The Shark Is Broken flounders to the end, with neither an engaging hook nor a line of compelling dialog to keep it afloat.

Here Lies Love

By any measure, Here Lies Love is a perfectly crafted, thrilling production that should make audiences very happy indeed.

Just for Us
62

But as entertaining as Edelman can be, especially with the right "us" in the audience, he hasn't yet figured out how to make that transition.

Once Upon a One More Time

Once Upon a One More Time, which is being touted in attorney-speak as "fully authorized and licensed post-conservatorship by Grammy Award-winning pop icon Britney Spears," is a surprisingly tasty treat, both for the eyes and for the ears.

Grey House

Even with the likely post-performance discussions and musings about "meaning," the greatest strength of this production of Grey House is the consistency of its preternatural mood.

Summer, 1976

Summer, 1976 comes off as a literary exercise, an enacted short story about a series of situational connections with others that happen to most of us most of the time.

Good Night, Oscar

There is a perhaps overused but most apt phrase to describe what is happening on stage at the Belasco, and that is "tour de force."

Camelot
Camelot

Talkin' Broadway · Apr 13, 2023

66

Ultimately, though, this Camelot revival falls on its own sword with its reworked book.

Fat Ham
Fat Ham

Talkin' Broadway · Apr 12, 2023

85

You can't help but feel welcome, drawn in, and caught up in the story.

Shucked
86

Add in an appealing, occasionally rowdy country-inflected score by the Grammy-winning songwriting team of Brandy Clark and Shane McAnally, and you've got yourself a show that is both whimsically hokey and welcoming as an old friend.

Life of Pi
89

Life of Pi is a show that succeeds on virtually every level, from its stunning visual effects to its deeply moving story about faith, survival, and the power of storytelling itself.

A Doll's House

Regardless, it is difficult to avoid feeling overwhelmed by the heavy-handedness of the production.

Pictures From Home

Makes you want to seek out an exhibition of Larry Sultan's photographs and study the real Jean and Irv as if you really do know them, even if it is all a matter of theatrical illusion.

The Collaboration

The same could also be said of The Collaboration, which relies on an intense curiosity about two of the most recognizable names in modern art.

& Juliet
& Juliet

Talkin' Broadway · Nov 17, 2022

76

All told, there is plenty of plot to go around, even if it does ask us to suspend a lot of disbelief along the way.

Walking with Ghosts

But what we are presented with, even as it is sparkled with Sinéad McKenna's supportive lighting design and Sinéad Diskin's original music and sound design, is both too much and not enough, a two-hour discourse that would best be appreciated by fans of the actor.

Topdog / Underdog

Every moment is filled with dialog and actions that convey layers of meaning with every word, every joke, every gesture, every bit of sexual boasting and competitiveness.

1776
1776

Talkin' Broadway · Oct 6, 2022

62

But overall, this remodeling job is all too raucous and too much in competition with itself to leave any sort of cohesive impression.

Cost of Living

What you get with Katy Sullivan's performance, in particular, will haunt you long after the final bows.

Leopoldstadt

Instead, Leopoldstadt gives us a linear narrative, a three-dimensional set of characters, and an adherence to credibility about the past that, if you are paying attention, also serves as a warning for the not-too-distant future.

The Kite Runner

That is all well and good, but a play is a play is a play, and this production of The Kite Runner amounts to a long evening of low-key narration and moments that have been culled from the novel.

Macbeth
Macbeth

Talkin' Broadway · Apr 30, 2022

42

Whatever his rationale, Gold likes to bring a downtown, experimental theater perspective to Broadway, where, really, it simply does not work, at least not with this production of Macbeth.

Birthday Candles

Debra Messing generally has too little to work with, only coming into her own as Ernestine herself comes into her own.