2024-2025 Broadway Season

Every show that opened on Broadway during the 2024-2025 season (July 2024 through June 2025), ranked by aggregated CriticScore ratings from dozens of outlets. This includes musicals, plays, and revivals — whether still running or closed.

42 shows | Last updated: September 2026

Sort:

1

Oh, Mary! Broadway play

Oh, Mary!

2+ years on Broadway· Closes Feb 13, 2027· From $77 ↗

2

Maybe Happy Ending Broadway musical

Maybe Happy Ending

1+ year on Broadway· From $59 ↗

3

Gypsy Broadway musical

Gypsy

Closed Aug 2025, after 8mos

4

English Broadway play

English

Closed Mar 2025, after 2mos

5

Dead Outlaw Broadway musical

Dead Outlaw

Closed Jun 2025, after 2mos

6

Purpose Broadway play

Purpose

Closed Aug 2025, after 5mos

7

John Proctor is the Villain Broadway play

John Proctor is the Villain

Closed Sep 2025, after 5mos

8

Buena Vista Social Club Broadway musical

Buena Vista Social Club

1+ year on Broadway· Closes Jan 17, 2027· From $62 ↗

9

Death Becomes Her Broadway musical

Death Becomes Her

Closed Jun 2026, after 1+yr

10

Just in Time Broadway musical

Just in Time

1+ year on Broadway· Closes Feb 7, 2027· From $77 ↗

11

Yellow Face Broadway play

Yellow Face

Closed Nov 2024, after 1mo

12

The Picture of Dorian Gray Broadway play

The Picture of Dorian Gray

Closed Jun 2025, after 3mos

13

Once Upon a Mattress Broadway musical

Once Upon a Mattress

Closed Nov 2024, after 3mos

14

Pirates! The Penzance Musical Broadway musical

Pirates! The Penzance Musical

Closed Jul 2025, after 3mos

15

Eureka Day Broadway play

Eureka Day

Closed Feb 2025, after 2mos

16

Real Women Have Curves Broadway musical

Real Women Have Curves

Closed Jun 2025, after 2mos

17

Sunset Boulevard Broadway musical

Sunset Boulevard

Closed Jul 2025, after 9mos

18

Operation Mincemeat Broadway musical

Operation Mincemeat

1+ year on Broadway· Closes Feb 14, 2027· From $63 ↗

19

The Hills of California Broadway play

The Hills of California

Closed Dec 2024, after 3mos

20

Stephen Sondheim's Old Friends Broadway musical

Stephen Sondheim's Old Friends

Closed Jun 2025, after 2mos

21

Cult of Love Broadway play

Cult of Love

Closed Feb 2025, after 2mos

22

Elf Broadway musical

Elf

Closed Jan 2025, after 2mos

23

Floyd Collins Broadway musical

Floyd Collins

Closed Jun 2025, after 2mos

24

Boop! The Musical Broadway musical

Boop! The Musical

Closed Jul 2025, after 3mos

25

JOB Broadway play

JOB

Closed Oct 2024, after 3mos

26

Our Town Broadway play

Our Town

Closed Jan 2025, after 3mos

27

The Roommate Broadway play

The Roommate

Closed Dec 2024, after 3mos

28

Good Night, and Good Luck Broadway play

Good Night, and Good Luck

Closed Jun 2025, after 2mos

29

Swept Away Broadway musical

Swept Away

Closed Dec 2024, after 1mo

30

Romeo + Juliet Broadway play

Romeo + Juliet

Closed Feb 2025, after 4mos

31

Glengarry Glen Ross Broadway play

Glengarry Glen Ross

Closed Jun 2025, after 3mos

32

All In: Comedy About Love Broadway play

All In: Comedy About Love

Closed Feb 2025, after 2mos

33

Stranger Things: The First Shadow Broadway play

Stranger Things: The First Shadow

1+ year on Broadway· Closes Jan 3, 2027· From $62 ↗

34

A Wonderful World: The Louis Armstrong Musical Broadway musical

A Wonderful World: The Louis Armstrong Musical

Closed Feb 2025, after 3mos

35

Call Me Izzy Broadway play

Call Me Izzy

Closed Aug 2025, after 2mos

36

SMASH Broadway musical

SMASH

Closed Jun 2025, after 2mos

37

Redwood Broadway musical

Redwood

Closed May 2025, after 3mos

38

Left on Tenth Broadway play

Left on Tenth

Closed Feb 2025, after 4mos

39

The Last Five Years Broadway musical

The Last Five Years

Closed Jun 2025, after 2mos

40

Othello Broadway play

Othello

Closed Jun 2025, after 3mos

41

McNeal Broadway play

McNeal

Closed Nov 2024, after 2mos

42

Tammy Faye Broadway musical

Tammy Faye

Closed Dec 2024, after 1mo

See Also

2023-2024 Season 2025-2026 Season Musicals Plays

How This Works

Shows are ranked by CriticScore, a weighted average of reviews from dozens of outlets. Top-tier publications (NYT, Vulture, Variety) carry more weight than smaller outlets. Toggle to Audience mode to see letter grades based on audience sentiment from multiple sources.

Learn about our scoring methodology →