Frozen vs Aladdin
Which Broadway show should you see? Compare CriticScore ratings, runtime, prices, and more.
Frozen
Which Show Should You See?
Based on CriticScore: Aladdin has a higher critic rating (70 vs 64).
Audiences say: Frozen earns a B (Shrugging), while Aladdin gets a B+ (Liking It).
Budget-friendly option: Aladdin has a $45 lottery for discounted tickets.
Critics find Disney's Frozen a mixed but commercially safe adaptation that delights young fans with faithful storytelling and strong performances by Levy and Murin, though it lacks the visionary stagecraft of The Lion King and often feels plodding despite spectacular effects.
Critics find Aladdin a visually spectacular but formulaic Disney adaptation that delivers solid family entertainment without breaking new ground. James Monroe Iglehart's exuberant Genie performance and the magic carpet scene earn widespread praise.