Harry Potter and the Cursed Child vs Stranger Things: The First Shadow
Which Broadway show should you see? Compare CriticScore ratings, runtime, prices, and more.
Which Show Should You See?
Based on CriticScore: Harry Potter and the Cursed Child has a higher critic rating (85 vs 65).
Audiences say: Harry Potter and the Cursed Child earns an A- (Liking It), while Stranger Things: The First Shadow gets an A (Loving It).
Short on time? Harry Potter and the Cursed Child runs 2h 55m while Stranger Things: The First Shadow runs 2h 45m.
Bringing kids? Harry Potter and the Cursed Child is recommended for Ages 10+, while Stranger Things: The First Shadow is Ages 12+.
Budget-friendly option: Both shows offer $40 lottery tickets — enter both for better chances!
Critics praise the spectacular stagecraft and astonishing magical effects, calling it a visual marvel that brings wizardry thrillingly to life. However, some find the story feels like expensive fan fiction, with mixed views on whether it truly honors the beloved franchise.
Critics are divided on this technically spectacular but narratively uneven prequel, with most praising the jaw-dropping special effects and stagecraft while questioning whether the convoluted three-hour story works for non-superfans.