Schmigadoon! vs & Juliet
Which Broadway show should you see? Compare CriticScore ratings, runtime, prices, and more.
Which Show Should You See?
Based on CriticScore: Schmigadoon! has a higher critic rating (79 vs 71).
Short on time? Schmigadoon! runs 2h 30m while & Juliet runs 2h 40m.
Bringing kids? Schmigadoon! is recommended for Ages 16+, while & Juliet is Ages 10+.
Budget-friendly option: Schmigadoon! has a $45 lottery for discounted tickets.
Critics embrace this affectionate Golden Age musical parody as pure joy for theater lovers, praising its sharp wit and expert craftsmanship, though some find the meta humor wears thin on stage after its TV origins.
Critics find this Max Martin jukebox musical a bubbly, exuberant guilty pleasure that reimagines Juliet's story with girl-power themes and pop hits. While some dismiss it as lightweight kitsch, most admit its infectious energy and chart-toppers are hard to resist.