Skip to main content
F

First Night Magazine

Tier 4: Independent blog. Counts 20% as much as a Tier 1 review.

Reviews

57

Average

59

Highest

98

Lowest

11

Among the least positive outlets (typical average: 75)1 different critic
SORT:
Nero
Nero

Guillermo Nazara · Nov 9, 2026

13

“With an unfinished score in every style except the one that suits the narrative and its setting and a book so clunky not even Alan Smithee would agree to sign it, Nero is bound to be as popular with the public as the man it portrays.”

Speculations
Speculations

Nov 5, 2026

51

“Most performances are decent, and some of them even shine.”

The Bridge

“Beyond the opportunity to watch someone who's endured the hardships of an ongoing clash in the flesh (one that has divided the entire world like no other), the production demonstrates virtually no strengths.”

Ceilidh The Musical

“Lively, endearing, and somewhat different, Ceilidh is a wondrous celebration of folklore and, above all, art's unparalleled ability to bring people together.”

The Moth
The Moth

Guillermo Nazara · Oct 30, 2026

40

“All of this makes The Moth a promising but clumsy play in the long run — something I doubt it's destined to.”

Roleplay
Roleplay

Oct 29, 2026

71

“Reilly’s performance is nonetheless captivating.”

Martin Guerre

“Albeit visually enticing, Warchus's take is unlikely to bring so many tears to the viewers' eyes (removing that tune might have something to do with it).”

Double Bill: Tell Me Straight & Aggy

“And other than the set, which isn't a design marvel but is at least satisfactory, there are virtually no redeeming features to justify putting these shows on — or coming to see them.”

The Cherry Orchard

“McPherson's inability to generate pathos and introspection has turned a philosophically and emotionally powerful script into a superficial and virtually boring piece of theatre.”

Affluenza
11

“Everything about it is dreadful: a thin plot, amateurish dialogue, a structure that falls apart from the beginning, and some of the most appalling acting I've seen in all these years as a critic — and as a viewer.”

Rent
Rent

Guillermo Nazara · Oct 11, 2026

25

“But its poor execution makes this revival of Rent a weak tenant in the West End neighbourhood.”

Hay Fever
Hay Fever

Oct 2, 2026

51

“The result isn’t tasteless, but it lacks spice — a lot of it.”

Darkling
Darkling

Sep 27, 2026

53

“The result is a lack of emotional bond.”

Table 17
Table 17

Sep 25, 2026

50

“Sadly, this is exactly what Table 17 offers.”

The Last Ship
The Last Ship

Sep 24, 2026

31

“The Last Ship can’t stay afloat, let alone make port.”

Million Dollar Quartet

“And so, Million Dollar Quartet is just an overpromiser that bets all its prospects of success on the work of others without doing anything by itself.”

Man to Man
Man to Man

Sep 16, 2026

53

“Urwin’s take on the material is extremely sterile and one-note.”

Night City
76

“Max Wilkinson's script delivers depth and poignancy through an insightful look into a modern-day crisis.”

The Children
The Children

Sep 11, 2026

71

“In the end, we are offered the sketches of what could be a stirring, thought-provoking play.”

Holy Fool
Holy Fool

Sep 4, 2026

32

“Eventually, Holy Fool is nothing but a superficial, unenticing, and painfully boring piece, whose only appeal is the name it intends to honour — and fails to do so miserably.”

As You Like It
As You Like It

Aug 24, 2026

98

“If laughter and engagement shall be the measures of a comedy’s success, this one had both in spades.”

Death Note: The Musical

“Wistfully, Death Note, The Musical is nothing but a superficial compilation of events with hardly any narrative impact — dramaturgically dead and with a nondescript score as the last nail in the coffin.”

Cats
Cats

Aug 9, 2026

55

“And that’s what makes Regent’s Park’s Open Air Theatre’s production passable in every sense of the word — it has a pass, but you can also pass on it.”

I'm Every Woman

“Dull and oblivious, I’m Every Woman is more likely to make viewers want to pack their bags and avoid sitting through stuff like that.”

Now You See Me Live

“Albeit amusing and generally well put together, this compilation of conventional illusions isn't a strong enough rival to other similar shows currently on offer across the London scene.”

Sinatra The Musical
31

“Sadly, this one is a long way from even dreaming of that title.”

High Society

“Overall, it's a nearly impeccable performance infused with classic-Broadway splendour, where plain entertainment is delivered in its finest form.”

Dear Jack, Dear Louise

“Although the germ of Dear Jack, Dear Louise exhibits aptitude, the script limits itself to an overly conventional execution, where a basic recipe is followed to the letter without any additional spices.”

John Proctor Is the Villain

“Although the plot is absorbing and the writing displays deftness, its embryonic dramaturgy makes it a passable but not remarkable experience at the theatre — and in no way matches the excellence of Miller's enduring work.”

THIS IS NOT ABOUT ME.
31

“In fact, there’s not much else you’ll be enticed to do other than count the minutes until it’s over.”

Daniel's Husband
Daniel's Husband

Dec 10, 2025

62

“Despite those final steps in the right direction, Daniel’s Husband‘s real potential remains in the shadows for the most part.”

Porn Play
Porn Play

Nov 24, 2025

77

“Beyond these flaws, the performance is, nonetheless, highly enjoyable.”

Othello
Othello

Nov 5, 2025

81

“Morris’s execution of Shakespeare’s harrowing recount is pleasantly solid.”

Every Brilliant Thing
83

“Surely, this last version of the piece should make it to anyone's October-November must-watch list.”

Clarkston
Clarkston

Sep 25, 2025

96

“Clarkston places itself as a deserving and long-awaited touchstone in the queer theatre repertoire.”

Cow | Deer
Cow | Deer

Sep 13, 2025

60

“But while all these achievements fairly deserve acknowledgment, the piece still remains closer to a well-executed germinal idea than a fully developed show.”

Born With Teeth
Born With Teeth

Sep 5, 2025

35

“Introducing audiences to a relevant, stimulating concept, but putting the provocation before the thought, Born With Teeth suffers from too many cavities in its delivery...”

Stereophonic
Stereophonic

Jun 17, 2025

56

“Coming up with the right themes but striving to stay in tune with its audience, Stereophonic sets up an interesting track for an enthralling narrative to unravel.”

The Great Gatsby
The Great Gatsby

Apr 25, 2025

78

“It's not the perfect musical, but it comes a long way from the current trend of rehashed movie titles.”

The Score
The Score

Feb 28, 2025

31

“There’s very little praise to spare for The Score, which mournfully plays against its title.”

Next to Normal
Next to Normal

Jun 28, 2024

77

“The experience is thrilling enough to make of it both enjoyable or worth.”

Peter Pan Goes Wrong

“With a few ups and downs and an akin group of bumps all throughout its delivery, the piece comes out as a slightly enjoyable though, unfortunately, not too memorable experience...”

The Wizard of Oz
The Wizard of Oz

Jul 14, 2023

75

“The result has not been disappointing, though. Clearly not what one would presumably expect to see in a show homaging a 1930s movie, the production has managed to keep the spark of wonder (no pun intended) that has captivated the imagination of so many children (and beyond) for almost a century now.”

Idiots Assemble: Spitting Image The Musical

“Laughter is more than guaranteed in this 2-hour satire of British decadence – where the Woke will get pissed and the Tories, screwed (in every sense).”

Brokeback Mountain
Brokeback Mountain

May 22, 2023

96

“The production functions flawlessly and with enticing theatricality.”

The Unfriend
The Unfriend

Jan 25, 2023

89

“With its audience roaring from beginning to end, there’s hardly any doubt that this show is, undoubtedly, one of the strongest offers of the start of the year...”

Marvellous
Marvellous

Oct 31, 2022

85

“The thing is that it’s a delightful show featuring a brilliant and much original narrative of a wowing real life, able to move and generate a good bunch of emotions (and reflections) at many levels.”