All Gold Lists
Critical Gold List™
The highest-rated Broadway shows by professional critics
10 shows | 2024-2025 Season
1
Oh, Mary!
PLAYORIGINALNOW PLAYING
Closes Feb 2027 · Opened Jul 2024
Critical Gold
88
2
Maybe Happy Ending
MUSICALORIGINALNOW PLAYING
Opened Nov 2024
Critical Gold
87
3
Gypsy
MUSICALREVIVALCLOSED
Closed Aug 2025 · Opened Dec 2024
Critical Gold
85
English
PLAYORIGINALCLOSED
Closed Mar 2025 · Opened Jan 2025
Critical Gold
84
Dead Outlaw
MUSICALORIGINALCLOSED
Closed Jun 2025 · Opened Apr 2025
Critical Gold
83
Purpose
PLAYORIGINALCLOSED
Closed Aug 2025 · Opened Mar 2025
Critical Gold
83
John Proctor is the Villain
PLAYORIGINALCLOSED
Closed Sep 2025 · Opened Apr 2025
Recommended
82
Buena Vista Social Club
MUSICALORIGINALNOW PLAYING
Closes Jan 2027 · Opened Mar 2025
Recommended
82
Death Becomes Her
MUSICALORIGINALCLOSED
Closed Jun 2026 · Opened Nov 2024
Recommended
80
Just in Time
MUSICALORIGINALNOW PLAYING
Closes Feb 2027 · Opened Apr 2025
Recommended
80