“Two hours and 25 minutes of sheer beauty in comic storytelling — a comedy that would make Sondheim proud.” By Alan Bresloff, Jun 30

Iceboy!
Goodman Theatre, Chicago, IL
Opened Jun 29, 2026 · Closed Aug 16, 2026 · Ran for 2 months
Regional production: tracked as a buzzy, well-reviewed show that could transfer to Broadway.
Critics' Take
Critics find this absurd musical comedy about Eugene O'Neill genuinely funny with standout performances from Mullally and Offerman, though some feel it's overlong and too campy, needing tightening to reach its full potential.
This show has closed. Tickets are no longer available.
Critic Scorecard
10 reviews- Tier 1: 100%
- Tier 2: 75%
- Tier 3: 40%
- Tier 4: 20%
“An absolute riot — a truly original and genuinely laugh-out-loud story with tight pacing and structure.” By Rachel Weinberg, Jun 30
“Capturing the feel of traditional musicals while incorporating new writing and comedy, Iceboy! enters into a new era of comedy shows.” By Allie Bugajski, Jun 30
“Flaws notwithstanding, I simply cannot imagine someone not enjoying themselves here.” By C.J. Fernandes, Jul 5
“Moment by moment, Bruni has it in great comedic shape, but no palpable human need drives the action and the stakes. Too fun to snooze, though.” By Chris Jones, Jun 30





