Skip to main content

Stage and Cinema

Tier 3: General coverage. Counts 40% as much as a Tier 1 review.

Reviews

83

Average

78

Highest

93

Lowest

18

79th most prolific outlet·288th most generous scorer·14 different critics
SORT:
Good Time Charlie

“Ryan J. Haddad’s affectionate tribute to his uncle celebrates the power of theater, though its homespun approach limits its emotional impact.”

Slam Frank

“The jaw-dropping absurdity will continue to tickle your funny bone at the same time you tilt your head, asking yourself, WTF?!”

Human Things
Human Things

Alex Simmons · Sep 25, 2026

84

“With sharp comedic turns, Human Things turns a remote island, an approaching storm, and two troubled marriages into an affecting night of theater.”

Arias with a Twist

“More story by association than cogent narrative, creators Arias and Twist have again brought the fun, laughs, theatricality, imagination, wonder, naughtiness, and coloring-outside-the-lines sensibility that made the show a success almost twenty years ago.”

Safe House
Safe House

Paola Bellu · Sep 10, 2026

75

“Fortunately, there is a solid play beneath the pile, and a passionate cast brings it to life with energy, conviction, and heart.”

The Real Ivanov
44

“Chekhov’s understanding of depression and social judgment remains remarkably contemporary; this production feels less timeless, and I suspect the problem is primarily one of direction rather than talent.”

Cat Cohen: Broad Strokes

“Only Cat Cohen can turn a sudden, life-threatening neurological event into an evening in which the audience laughs almost continuously and springs to its feet in applause the moment she finishes.”

The Vessel
63

“The play offers its own thoughtful, if imperfect, meditation on the people who watch over it.”

An American Daughter

“Funny without being frivolous, political without becoming didactic, and deeply compassionate without ever surrendering its bite, Wasserstein’s writing still lands.”

The Winter's Tale

“At the Delacorte Theater, director Daniel Sullivan and a brilliant cast serve up a delicious cocktail of irrational jealousy, paranoia, tyrannical tantrums, bucolic escapades, and miraculous reunions beneath the New York summer night sky.”

The Saviors
84

“The Saviors is a compelling drama that wrestles with faith, tradition, trust, and trauma.”

Giulia: The Poison Queen of Palermo

“Thanks to director Mary Zimmerman, scenic designer Daniel Ostling, and lighting designer T.J. Gerckens, there is remarkable artistry on display at PAC NYC, where the thrilling new musical Giulia: The Poison Queen of Palermo opened tonight.”

Misterman
Misterman

Paola Bellu · Jul 1, 2026

88

“It is a work of emotional and intellectual resonance, threaded with humor, shadowed by darkness, and guided by an unmistakably individual vision.”

A Walk on the Moon

“After intermission, the emotional stakes deepen, allowing the musical’s warmth and sincerity to shine through.”

Camping
Camping

Gregory Fletcher · Jun 20, 2026

88

“The forward momentum feels assured from first scene to last, as though the playwright and director know exactly where it’s going and trust us to keep up.”

Girl, Interrupted

“Girl, Interrupted is doing something genuinely difficult: rendering the texture of a disordered memory with theatrical and musical honesty, without sentimentality and without exploitation.”

Jerome
Jerome

Gregory Fletcher · Jun 2, 2026

91

“Jerome is a rewarding theatrical journey—one that balances intimacy with ambition, humor with heart, and romance with hard-earned wisdom.”

The Emporium

“For theatre historians and students—or for anyone who wants to witness two exceptional actors doing extraordinary work—The Emporium makes a compelling, if complicated, case for its own existence.”

The Maids
78

“It is theatre as sensory bombardment: highly theatrical, intensely performed, and impossible to ignore.”

The Mystery of Edwin Drood

“The Mystery of Edwin Drood is a challenging, unusual, and complex piece to pull off, and it is no mystery why J2 Spotlight succeeds so well with this piece: dedication, talent, and spunk.”

The People Versus Lenny Bruce

“Anthony’s performance captures Lenny’s urgency while taking moments to recognize the absurdity of being dragged into court over words, and struggling with being denied a chance to perform his act in court.”

The Balusters

“The Balusters is not just a fabulous new play; it is a vital, invigorating reminder that even the most polite rooms can contain seismic change.”

Proof
Proof

Paulanne Simmons · Apr 23, 2026

44

“If Proof is a play that explores the relationship between extreme intelligence and mental illness, we must believe Catherine and Robert have both.”

Fallen Angels
Fallen Angels

Paola Bellu · Apr 22, 2026

85

“The acting is absolutely first-rate, the staging delights, and you will certainly leave feeling better for it.”

Titus Andronicus

“Andronicus is so vivid it will convert skeptics: It’s memorable for seasoned theatergoers and will be a revelation for anyone who usually steers clear of Shakespeare.”

Seagull: True Story

“Molochnikov’s production doesn’t merely argue for theater’s relevance—it embodies it, with restless energy and a palpable love of the form.”

Public Charge

“While the production’s cool, methodical staging keeps the audience at arm’s length, the story it tells—of an immigrant who rises to shape global policy—remains a compelling and distinctly American narrative, even when the drama itself struggles to fully ignite.”

Monte Cristo

“For all its ambition, Monte Cristo presents a strong, impressive debut—one that occasionally struggles to reconcile its tonal shifts but never lacks for theatrical sweep or conviction.”

BIGFOOT!
BIGFOOT!

Alex Simmons · Mar 18, 2026

87

“Campy, over the top, and utterly ridiculous, Bigfoot! follows in the tradition of hilarious musicals like Evil Dead or Avenger.”

Spare Parts

“In an era when new plays often struggle to find both intellectual rigor and theatrical propulsion, Spare Parts manages to deliver both.”

The Reservoir

“But if you find the cute but irrelevant and obvious jokes tiring, you may discover that after two hours and fifteen minutes, you’ve had more than enough.”

Burnout Paradise

“But if you are looking for a mindless, game-like performance that is guaranteed to make you laugh, don’t think twice, this is Paradise.”

The Monsters
The Monsters

Alex Simmons · Feb 11, 2026

89

“The Monsters is a layered, emotionally muscular play powered by two formidable performances and technical flair that matches a script full of duels and drama alike.”

Chess
Chess

Carol Rocamora · Dec 6, 2025

78

“Nevertheless, entertainment is the chief value of this sensational Broadway revival.”

Liberation
Liberation

Alex Simmons · Oct 30, 2025

86

“And how do we get it back?” That’s one of the questions posed about the condition of gender equality in 2025. America at the start of Liberation, Bess Wohl’s vivid new memory play that brings the 1970s women’s movement roaring back to life at the James Theatre.”

Ragtime
Ragtime

Carol Rocamora · Oct 17, 2025

91

“For me, Ragtime was a cathartic collective experience, given what we are living through today in our traumatized country.”

Art
Art

Paola Bellu · Sep 16, 2025

89

“Yasmina Reza’s Art returned to Broadway last night starring Neil Patrick Harris, Bobby Cannavale, and James Corden, and it is a tight, acidic joyride through ego and insecurity, wickedly funny.”

AMAZE Magic
AMAZE Magic

Paola Bellu · Aug 13, 2025

78

“I did not leave with my jaw dropped but with a flicker of childhood wonder reignited, and a loving nod to the memories and mentors that taught me to find the extraordinary in the everyday.”

Just in Time
82

“It’s a slam-bang, love-struck miracle — and baby, it’s right on time.”

Gypsy
Gypsy

Paola Bellu · Dec 20, 2024

93

“Audra McDonald in Gypsy makes it even more significant, something you will not forget.”

Death Becomes Her

“Death Becomes Her is a crowd-pleasing hit that deserves to be around forever — well, at least for a good long time.”

Bad Kreyòl
81

“Morisseau (Skeleton Crew, Pipeline, Confederates) offers an affecting, engaging, often funny yet fundamentally human (and messy) exploration of relationships, otherness, colonialism, class and identity.”

JOB
JOB

Paola Bellu · Jul 30, 2024

88

“Directed by Michael Herwitz, this tense two-character psychological thriller is thought-provoking and absolutely engaging, a must see for Boomers, Millennials, and Gen Z.”

CATS: The Jellicle Ball

“Come for the catchy songs, stay for the ballroom extravaganza, and remember that while the cast may be extravagant and constantly one-upping and over-the-topping each other, it’s not a feature or a bug, it’s the whole point.”

Hell's Kitchen

“Hell's Kitchen is a sumptuous, shining, satisfying show that has great performances, a compelling story, enthralling music, creative production design, exciting choreography and a huge heart.”

Stereophonic
Stereophonic

Paola Bellu · Apr 19, 2024

44

“Unfortunately the action is diluted by Daniel Aukin ’s slow direction (he could cut an hour off without changing the plot) and the levity of the script by David Adjmi.”

The Outsiders

“When Ponyboy expresses in song what he’ll bring to being a future writer (‘And in his memory, I’ll stay gold’) it also speaks for the creative team and performers, as this production is pure theatrical gold.”

The Comeuppance
The Comeuppance

Jul 7, 2023

87

“Branden Jacobs-Jenkins’ bold new play doesn’t waste a moment in embracing the creepiness that has invaded Ursula’s home.”

Fat Ham
Fat Ham

Tony Frankel · Apr 16, 2023

78

“Like any big spread at a cookout, it looks great but turns out some of the dishes are hit and miss.”

MJ The Musical
MJ The Musical

Apr 15, 2022

91

“This is a star-making tour de force performance requiring a level of singing, dancing and nuanced acting rarely seen on stage.”

Tootsie
Tootsie

Harvey Perr · Apr 29, 2019

87

“This is what tourists come to Broadway for — to get a taste of what it’s like when pros turn on the heat.”

John Lithgow: Stories By Heart

“Few performers possess the charisma and, frankly, the chops to straddle a stage alone and draw you in so fully – but Lithgow might be that great exception.”

Marvin's Room

“All-in-all a very pleasant outing for a Sunday afternoon (42nd Street notwithstanding).”

Ruthless! The Musical

“He’s endeavoring to make fun of bad musicals with a musical that is worse than a lot of the ones he’s trying to make fun of.”

Bullets Over Broadway

“Despite its promising plot, Bullets Over Broadway, even with all the glitter of William Ivey Long’s costumes and Santo Loquasto’s scenery, is fairly lackluster.”

Mothers and Sons

“McNally's work is outstanding. It transcends the issue of gay-acceptance and puts its question more broadly: Can anyone love us for us?”

🎭
Picnic

Dmitry Zvonkov · Jan 13, 2013

71

“Not much in this very professional production feels like it needs to be said.”

Evita
Evita

Thomas Antoinne · Apr 23, 2012

44

“Today the story of an ambitious woman using her sexuality to get ahead seems trite and quaint.”

The Scottsboro Boys
90

“The Scottsboro Boys is an antic shindig with a dark heart…unique and powerful- an eruption of entertainment.”

La Bête
La Bête

Oct 23, 2010

74

“La Bête's funny moments outnumber its tiresome stretches (and those funny moments are very funny indeed), and the skilled comic performances of Rylance, Hyde Pierce, and Ouimette are pure pleasure to behold.”

Stage and Cinema - Theatre Reviews (Tier 3) | Broadway Scorecard