Skip to main content
Pre-Existing Condition Off-Broadway play poster
PLAYREVIVALOFF-BROADWAYNOW PLAYING

Pre-Existing Condition

Greenwich House Theater · 1h 15m

Opened Sep 14, 2026 · Closes Jan 9, 2027

Critics' Take

Ireland's intimate domestic abuse drama earns strong praise for its nuanced writing and restraint, with critics highlighting Nyong'o's powerful performance, though some find the 75-minute piece overly quiet or uneven in its impact.

Critic Scorecard

25 reviews
Sort:
Counts
  • Tier 1: 100%
  • Tier 2: 75%
  • Tier 3: 40%
  • Tier 4: 20%
The Guardian logo
The Guardian

“Ireland’s play, while it can’t be a roadmap, is a tightly designed, gorgeously felt blueprint.” By Juan A. Ramirez, Sep 155/5 stars

Culture Sauce logo
Culture Sauce

“Ireland, who based the play on her own well-publicized experience with an actor-boyfriend during a London production . has written an actorly play that allows its entire cast to shine.” By Thom Geier, Sep 145/5 stars

Front Row Center logo
Front Row Center

“Ireland’s debut writing effort—she’s also an actress and fixture of the New York theater scene—is compelling and devastating.” By Tom Storch, Sep 15

USA Today logo
USA Today

“With its sage script and unshakeable leading turn, ‘Pre-Existing Condition’ offers a vital reminder that healing isn’t linear and pain cannot be neatly qualified.” By Patrick Ryan, Sep 15

Off Off Online logo
Off Off Online

“It is a quiet, unflashy play—75 minutes, sensitively directed by Maria Dizzia, with subtle performances from an ensemble of four—but no less devastating for its restraint.” By Colin Macdonald, Sep 24

How this score works →