“What an inventive and delightful show this was.” By Katarina La Poll, Oct 19
PLAYOFF-BROADWAYNOW PLAYING
Two Girls
Cherry Lane Theatre · 1h
Opened Oct 18, 2026 · Closes Nov 29, 2026
1 Rave
4 Positive
3 Mixed
Critics' Take
Critics find this verbatim play about the infamous viral video an intriguing but uneven exploration of internet porn's impact on millennials, praising its provocative concept while questioning its execution.
Critic Scorecard
8 reviews1 Rave
4 Positive
3 Mixed
Sort:
Weighted by outlet tier · Counts
- Tier 1: 100%
- Tier 2: 75%
- Tier 3: 40%
- Tier 4: 20%
“Two Girls confirmed me what’s worth watching: not that notorious video but the career of a playwright on the ascent.” By Dan Rubins, Oct 19
“The playwright Eliya Smith’s strange, unexpectedly tender theatrical investigation draws on interviews with eight men to unpack the legacy of the infamous viral phenomenon 2 Girls 1 Cup...” By Joey Sims, Oct 22
“Chloe Claudel and Juliana Sass hilariously perform these interviews verbatim.” By Allison Considine, Oct 19
“That final twist, for me, is more successful intellectually than emotionally.” By Loren Noveck, Oct 20
