Skip to main content
All Predictions

Tony Awards Predictions

How our per-category model would have predicted the 2017 Tony Awards.

93.6%Our #1 pick wins the Tonyacross 12 seasons · tap to see track record
44/47

Our #1 matches the Tony winner across 12 seasons · 93.6% match rate

Best Musical12/12 100%
Best Play12/12 100%
Best Revival Musical11/11 100%
Best Revival Play9/12 75%

Season by season

SeasonMus.PlayR. Mus.R. Play
2025-2026
2024-2025
2023-2024
2022-2023
2021-2022
2019-2020
2018-2019
2017-2018
2016-2017
2015-2016
2014-2015
2013-2014

Where we missed (3)

Our #1 didn't match the Tony winner in these category-seasons. Most are voter-sentiment upsets (cultural significance, star power) that blended scores can't fully capture.

2018-2019 · Best Revival Play
Our #1: The Waverly Gallery
Tony: The Boys in the Band
2014-2015 · Best Revival Play
Our #1: The Elephant Man
Tony: Skylight
2013-2014 · Best Revival Play
Our #1: The Glass Menagerie
Tony: A Raisin in the Sun

Prediction Report Card

4/4

Musical

Correct
Dear Evan Hansen

Our #1 pick

Dear Evan Hansen

Prediction Score86
Critics
87
Audience
A-
Awards
89

Play

Correct
Oslo

Our #1 pick

Oslo

Prediction Score75
Critics
84
Audience
B+
Awards
85

Revival Musical

Correct
Hello, Dolly!

Our #1 pick

Hello, Dolly!

Prediction Score89
Critics
85
Audience
A
Awards
84

Revival Play

Correct
Jitney

Our #1 pick

Jitney

Prediction Score89
Critics
86
Audience
A-
Awards
77

Best Musical

Correct

New musicals eligible for the top musical prize.

Best Play

Correct

New plays eligible for the top play prize.

Best Revival of a Musical

Correct

Musical revivals competing for best revival honors.

Best Revival of a Play

Correct

Play revivals competing for best revival honors.

Performer & Craft Categories

Historical 2016-2017 nominees with critic scores, audience grades, and Award Score.

Best Book of a Musical

CriticScore
AudienceGrade
AwardScore
PressPicks
Come From Away

Irene Sankoff & David Hein

OCCDD
79
A+
80
Dear Evan Hansen

Steven Levenson

OCC
87
A-
89
Groundhog Day

Danny Rubin

71
B+
66

Best Original Score

CriticScore
AudienceGrade
AwardScore
PressPicks
Come From Away

Irene Sankoff & David Hein

79
A+
80
Dear Evan Hansen

Benj Pasek & Justin Paul

DD
87
A-
89
Groundhog Day

Tim Minchin

71
B+
66

Best Actor in a Musical

Best Actress in a Musical

PressPicks
War Paint

Best Actor in a Play

PressPicks
Oslo
Present Laughter

Best Actress in a Play

PressPicks
Oslo

Best Direction of a Musical

CriticScore
AudienceGrade
AwardScore
PressPicks
Come From Away

Christopher Ashley

OCC
79
A+
80
Dear Evan Hansen

Michael Greif

87
A-
89
Groundhog Day

Matthew Warchus

71
B+
66
Hello, Dolly!

Jerry Zaks

85
A+
84

Best Direction of a Play

CriticScore
AudienceGrade
AwardScore
PressPicks
85
A-
64
Indecent

Rebecca Taichman

OCC
83
A-
66
Jitney

Ruben Santiago-Hudson

DD
86
A
77
Oslo

Bartlett Sher

84
A-
85
The Little Foxes

Daniel Sullivan

85
A-
69

Best Featured Actor in a Musical

Best Featured Actress in a Musical

PressPicks

Best Featured Actor in a Play

PressPicks
The Front Page

Best Featured Actress in a Play

PressPicks

Best Choreography

CriticScore
AudienceGrade
AwardScore
PressPicks
Bandstand

Andy Blankenbuehler

DD
74
B+
53
Come From Away

Kelly Devine

79
A+
80
Groundhog Day

Peter Darling & Ellen Kane

71
B+
66

Best Orchestrations

CriticScore
AudienceGrade
AwardScore
PressPicks
Bandstand

Bill Elliott & Greg Anthony Rassen

74
B+
53
Dear Evan Hansen

Alex Lacamoire

87
A-
89
Hello, Dolly!

Larry Hochman

85
A+
84

Best Scenic Design of a Musical

CriticScore
AudienceGrade
AwardScore
PressPicks
Groundhog Day

Rob Howell

71
B+
66
Hello, Dolly!

Santo Loquasto

85
A+
84
War Paint

David Korins

71
B-
45

Best Scenic Design of a Play

CriticScore
AudienceGrade
AwardScore
PressPicks
Jitney

David Gallo

86
A
77
Oslo

Michael Yeargan

84
A-
85
The Front Page

Douglas W. Schmidt

71
B
34
74
A-
41

Best Costume Design of a Musical

CriticScore
AudienceGrade
AwardScore
PressPicks
Anastasia

Linda Cho

66
B+
48
Hello, Dolly!

Santo Loquasto

85
A+
84
War Paint

Catherine Zuber

71
B-
45

Best Costume Design of a Play

CriticScore
AudienceGrade
AwardScore
PressPicks
85
A-
64
Jitney

Toni-Leslie James

86
A
77
Present Laughter

Susan Hilferty

80
B+
67
The Little Foxes

Jane Greenwood

85
A-
69

Best Lighting Design of a Musical

CriticScore
AudienceGrade
AwardScore
PressPicks
Come From Away

Howell Binkley

79
A+
80
Dear Evan Hansen

Japhy Weideman

87
A-
89
Hello, Dolly!

Natasha Katz

85
A+
84

Best Lighting Design of a Play

CriticScore
AudienceGrade
AwardScore
PressPicks
A Doll's House, Part 2

Jennifer Tipton

85
A-
64
Indecent

Christopher Akerlind

83
A-
66
Jitney

Jane Cox

86
A
77
Oslo

Donald Holder

84
A-
85

Rankings are derived from aggregated critic reviews. Tony eligibility based on opening dates within the 2016-2017 season. Category classifications (new vs. revival) are subject to official Tony Awards Administration Committee rulings.

Score model updated 2026-05-16. Awards Score now uses tier-weighted precursor nominations (Drama League, OCC, Drama Desk). Backtest accuracy: 41 of 47 contests (87%) across 12 years of Tony history.