Skip to main content
All Predictions

Tony Awards Predictions

How our per-category model would have predicted the 2018 Tony Awards.

93.6%Our #1 pick wins the Tonyacross 12 seasons · tap to see track record
44/47

Our #1 matches the Tony winner across 12 seasons · 93.6% match rate

Best Musical12/12 100%
Best Play12/12 100%
Best Revival Musical11/11 100%
Best Revival Play9/12 75%

Season by season

SeasonMus.PlayR. Mus.R. Play
2025-2026
2024-2025
2023-2024
2022-2023
2021-2022
2019-2020
2018-2019
2017-2018
2016-2017
2015-2016
2014-2015
2013-2014

Where we missed (3)

Our #1 didn't match the Tony winner in these category-seasons. Most are voter-sentiment upsets (cultural significance, star power) that blended scores can't fully capture.

2018-2019 · Best Revival Play
Our #1: The Waverly Gallery
Tony: The Boys in the Band
2014-2015 · Best Revival Play
Our #1: The Elephant Man
Tony: Skylight
2013-2014 · Best Revival Play
Our #1: The Glass Menagerie
Tony: A Raisin in the Sun

Prediction Report Card

4/4

Musical

Correct
The Band's Visit

Our #1 pick

The Band's Visit

Prediction Score83
Critics
88
Audience
B+
Awards
95

Play

Correct
Harry Potter and the Cursed Child

Our #1 pick

Harry Potter and the Cursed Child

Prediction Score66
Critics
85
Audience
A-
Awards
86

Revival Musical

Correct
Once on This Island

Our #1 pick

Once on This Island

Prediction Score88
Critics
84
Audience
A
Awards
74

Revival Play

Correct
Angels in America

Our #1 pick

Angels in America

Prediction Score93
Critics
88
Audience
A+
Awards
91

Best Musical

Correct

New musicals eligible for the top musical prize.

Best Play

Correct

New plays eligible for the top play prize.

Best Revival of a Musical

Correct

Musical revivals competing for best revival honors.

Best Revival of a Play

Correct

Play revivals competing for best revival honors.

Performer & Craft Categories

Historical 2017-2018 nominees with critic scores, audience grades, and Award Score.

Best Book of a Musical

CriticScore
AudienceGrade
AwardScore
PressPicks
Frozen

Jennifer Lee

64
B
47
Mean Girls

Tina Fey

OCCDD
76
B+
67
77
B+
76
The Band's Visit

Itamar Moses

88
B+
95

Best Original Score

CriticScore
AudienceGrade
AwardScore
PressPicks
Frozen

Kristen Anderson-Lopez & Robert Lopez

64
B
47
Mean Girls

Jeff Richmond & Nell Benjamin

DD
76
B+
67
SpongeBob SquarePants

Yolanda Adams & Sara Bareilles & Jonathan Coulton & Cyndi Lauper & Rob Hyman & John Legend & T.I. & Domani & Lil' C

OCC
77
B+
76
The Band's Visit

David Yazbek

OCCDD
88
B+
95

Best Actor in a Musical

PressPicks
Carousel
The New York Times
Variety
Culture Sauce
New York Theatre Guide
Entertainment Weekly
The New York Sun
TheaterMania
Slant Magazine
Time Out New York
The Hollywood Reporter
Deadline
City Guide New York
Elle
Boston Globe
The New York Times
The Wrap
Parade
r/Broadway
1 Minute Critic

Best Actress in a Musical

PressPicks
Carousel
Summer

Best Actor in a Play

PressPicks

Best Actress in a Play

Best Direction of a Musical

CriticScore
AudienceGrade
AwardScore
PressPicks
Mean Girls

Casey Nicholaw

76
B+
67
My Fair Lady

Bartlett Sher

83
A-
70
Once on This Island

Michael Arden

84
A
74
SpongeBob SquarePants

Tina Landau

OCCDD
77
B+
76
The Band's Visit

David Cromer

88
B+
95

Best Direction of a Play

CriticScore
AudienceGrade
AwardScore
PressPicks
85
A-
86
The Iceman Cometh

George C. Wolfe

73
B
49
Three Tall Women

Joe Mantello

87
A
79
Travesties

Patrick Marber

85
B-
51

Best Featured Actor in a Musical

PressPicks

Best Featured Actress in a Musical

PressPicks
My Fair Lady

Best Featured Actor in a Play

Best Featured Actress in a Play

PressPicks
Variety
Culture Sauce
New York Theatre Guide
Entertainment Weekly
Slant Magazine
Time Out New York
The Hollywood Reporter
Deadline
City Guide New York
Elle
Chicago Tribune
Parade
r/Broadway
1 Minute Critic

Best Choreography

CriticScore
AudienceGrade
AwardScore
PressPicks
Carousel

Justin Peck

OCCDD
74
B+
71
85
A-
86
Mean Girls

Casey Nicholaw

76
B+
67
My Fair Lady

Christopher Gattelli

83
A-
70
SpongeBob SquarePants

Christopher Gattelli

77
B+
76

Best Orchestrations

CriticScore
AudienceGrade
AwardScore
PressPicks
Carousel

Jonathan Tunick

74
B+
71
Mean Girls

John Clancy

76
B+
67
Once on This Island

AnnMarie Milazzo & Michael Starobin

84
A
74
77
B+
76
The Band's Visit

Jamshied Sharifi

88
B+
95

Best Scenic Design of a Musical

CriticScore
AudienceGrade
AwardScore
PressPicks
Mean Girls

Finn Ross & Adam Young & Scott Pask

76
B+
67
My Fair Lady

Michael Yeargan

83
A-
70
84
A
74
77
B+
76
88
B+
95

Best Scenic Design of a Play

CriticScore
AudienceGrade
AwardScore
PressPicks
Farinelli and the King

Jonathan Fensom

75
B+
50
85
A-
86
The Iceman Cometh

Santo Loquasto

73
B
49
Three Tall Women

Miriam Buether

87
A
79

Best Costume Design of a Musical

CriticScore
AudienceGrade
AwardScore
PressPicks
Carousel

Ann Roth

74
B+
71
Mean Girls

Gregg Barnes

76
B+
67
My Fair Lady

Catherine Zuber

83
A-
70
84
A
74
77
B+
76

Best Costume Design of a Play

CriticScore
AudienceGrade
AwardScore
PressPicks
Farinelli and the King

Jonathan Fensom

75
B+
50
85
A-
86
73
B
49
87
A
79

Best Lighting Design of a Musical

CriticScore
AudienceGrade
AwardScore
PressPicks
Carousel

Brian MacDevitt

74
B+
71
My Fair Lady

Donald Holder

83
A-
70
Once on This Island

Jules Fisher & Peggy Eisenhauer

84
A
74
77
B+
76
The Band's Visit

Tyler Micoleau

88
B+
95

Best Lighting Design of a Play

CriticScore
AudienceGrade
AwardScore
PressPicks
75
B+
50
Junk

Ben Stanton

71
B
36
The Iceman Cometh

Jules Fisher & Peggy Eisenhauer

73
B
49

Best Sound Design of a Musical

CriticScore
AudienceGrade
AwardScore
PressPicks
Carousel

Scott Lehrer

74
B+
71
Mean Girls

Brian Ronan

76
B+
67
Once on This Island

Peter Hylenski

84
A
74
SpongeBob SquarePants

Walter Trarbach & Mike Dobson

77
B+
76
88
B+
95

Best Sound Design of a Play

CriticScore
AudienceGrade
AwardScore
PressPicks
1984

Tom Gibbons

69
B-
14
The Iceman Cometh

Dan Moses Schreier

73
B
49
Travesties

Adam Cork

85
B-
51

Rankings are derived from aggregated critic reviews. Tony eligibility based on opening dates within the 2017-2018 season. Category classifications (new vs. revival) are subject to official Tony Awards Administration Committee rulings.

Score model updated 2026-05-16. Awards Score now uses tier-weighted precursor nominations (Drama League, OCC, Drama Desk). Backtest accuracy: 41 of 47 contests (87%) across 12 years of Tony history.