Skip to main content
L

Liam O'Dell

Tier 3: General coverage. Counts 40% as much as a Tier 1 review.

Reviews

105

Average

62

Highest

97

Lowest

18

Among the least positive outlets (typical average: 75)1 different critic
SORT:
Hamlet Hail to the Thief

“The rock group’s gritty sound reenergises the rage and vengeance within the text, but the marriage between music and script isn’t strong as it could or should be.”

Dogstar
Dogstar

Liam O'Dell · Nov 12, 2026

39

“The result is a play to which it is impossible to pay attention, because it seemingly has no idea where it’s heading and what point it wishes to make.”

The Bridge
The Bridge

Liam O'Dell · Nov 3, 2026

77

“Much like his acclaimed debut The Horse of Jenin, the insight into Palestinian life, the worldbuilding and the good humour with which the story is told is what makes The Bridge an entertaining and informative tale, about the hopes and dreams which keep Palestinians moving and looking forward.”

Ceilidh The Musical
94

“The depth of the connection that is formed between audience, company and story in Ceilidh is powerful, rare and precious.”

Memoriam
Memoriam

Liam O'Dell · Oct 30, 2026

66

“This straightforward and original premise is somewhat weighed down by overly technical, corporate language...”

Roleplay
Roleplay

Liam O'Dell · Oct 27, 2026

18

“Plain and purposeless, this play about a problematic podcaster isn’t worth watching or listening to.”

The Pianist
The Pianist

Liam O'Dell · Oct 26, 2026

62

“The stage play does well to platform the pianist’s work, and there are whole segments of the production spent listening and appreciating his work in its entirety, but we get little sense of the man beyond this.”

The Master Builder

“Put simply, in the pursuit of minimalism, this version of The Master Builder is lacking some essential building blocks to make this a layered version of Ibsen’s classic.”

Some Woman
Some Woman

Liam O'Dell · Oct 21, 2026

95

“Edmundson’s Some Woman is a chilling story with an exceptional lead performance and intimate direction which continues the Dorfman’s run of shocking and thought-provoking theatre.”

Nina
Nina

Liam O'Dell · Oct 19, 2026

41

“Sadly, NINA becomes too tangled in the technical to allow for any key message to emerge fully.”

Cadel: Lungs On Legs

“The energy and passion put into CADEL: Lungs on Legs is palpable, evidenced by some fascinating trivia shared by Delves after the curtain call.”

Triumph
Triumph

Liam O'Dell · Oct 18, 2026

63

“There’s nothing enlightening about being reminded of the past actions of the Trump administration through these parallels, even if the act of recollection is entertaining in and of itself.”

Baby
Baby

Liam O'Dell · Oct 16, 2026

80

“Standing tall above the bureaucracy, the files and an uncaring system, she proves herself to her audience, in a sobering piece of theatre.”

The Cherry Orchard

“As such, Rickson and McPherson’s The Cherry Orchard is far more entertaining than it is intellectual and emotive, meaning it ought to have been a lot more fruitful.”

Fences
Fences

Liam O'Dell · Oct 9, 2026

40

“For a production with music hardwired into its core, it lacks the pacing and range to make for an engaging and worthwhile three hours.”

The Hungry Ghost

“Ailin Conant’s 100-miles-per-hour direction makes this an utter thrill to watch, and gives weight to those rare moments of silence – where Girl realises she’s possessed, and her mother gives a scathing assessment of how messy her life is.”

Affluenza
Affluenza

Liam O'Dell · Oct 6, 2026

39

“The family at the heart of Affluenza may be rich in terms of money, but the play is far from rich in terms of detail.”

Table 17
Table 17

Liam O'Dell · Sep 28, 2026

78

“With playful direction from Zhailon Levingston and a stunning set and lighting design partnership between Amy Jane Cook and Matt Haskins respectively, you’ll definitely want a seat at this table.”

🎭

“António Fonseca’s character, often indulging in bittersweet nostalgia, presents a hauntingly familiar near-future with how his story develops, as he talks of the dismantling of the national health service and having to pay for ‘premium’ palliative care.”

The Turn of the Screw

“The original is said to be the inspiration for The Women in Black, but Emilia playwright Morgan Lloyd Malcolm’s stage adaptation of Henry James’ novella The Turn of the Screw is missing the scares and the psychology which would support such a claim.”

Darkling
Darkling

Liam O'Dell · Sep 16, 2026

70

“This play offers an essential and important account.”

Jane Eyre
Jane Eyre

Liam O'Dell · Sep 13, 2026

40

“This musical staging of an iconic book and character lacks the confidence one associates with this remarkable woman.”

The Children
The Children

Liam O'Dell · Sep 12, 2026

64

“The piece just about manages to keep us engaged throughout, but it could have done with a few more hints about its final destination during the performance itself.”

BLOODSPORT: After Helen of Troy

“Much like 1536, this present-day reworking of Helen of Troy by Pickett once again has a misogynistic society in its periphery, and while it never fully comes to the fore, strong performances and an unnerving intensity make it a punchy and engaging watch.”

The Story
The Story

Sep 8, 2026

39

“The Story tries to be bigger than… well… the story , but a single thread tying everything together is missing.”

Holy Fool
Holy Fool

Liam O'Dell · Sep 4, 2026

35

“Bending from a political thriller into a last-minute story of friendship, and not quite going into enough detail to be passable as a biographical piece, Holy Fool lacks a clear structure or climax.”

Electra / Persona
64

“Make no mistake, Electra/Persona is excellently staged, with strong performances, but ironically, for a play about individuality, this double bill struggles to coalesce.”

Abigail’s Party

“It pushes the pleasantries of the decade to breaking point, and makes for an entertaining night at the theatre.”

Cats
Cats

Liam O'Dell · Aug 8, 2026

54

“Its presentation is uneven and disjointed, and while there are components of this Cats revival which can be appreciated in isolation, McOnie’s vibrant choreography and Lloyd Webber’s classic score struggle to operate in harmony.”

I'm Every Woman

“I’m Every Woman is more of a passive watch than an active one, and that doesn’t really align with the energy and commanding presence of a musical icon as fierce as Chaka Khan.”

Tao of Glass
Tao of Glass

Liam O'Dell · Jul 31, 2026

95

“The contemplation and deep thought that Tao of Glass inspires is truly unique, unlike anything else I’ve experienced before in a theatre.”

The Importance of Being Oscar

“If The Importance of Being Oscar sets out to inject some colour into the life of Oscar Wilde outside of the confines of his words, then a monochrome – and, sadly, mono tone – production only goes so far.”

The World Is Full of Married Men

“The puppetry is novel with hilarious rough edges, Collins' text is vivid, and its critique of misogyny – while simply expressed and reinforced on multiple occasions – is thought-provoking and impactful.”

The Oresteia
The Oresteia

Liam O'Dell · Jul 15, 2026

60

“The Oresteia is hardly stimulating on an intellectual level – and certainly not helped by the near impossible level of focus and processing required of an audience member described in previous paragraphs – but occasionally engaging over a mammoth 3 hour and 30 minute runtime.”

Archduke
Archduke

Liam O'Dell · Jul 1, 2026

42

“And in the case of Archduke, I fear there’s little here that’s memorable.”

Relics
Relics

Liam O'Dell · Jun 28, 2026

60

“What exactly is the point of all of this, then, if the serious message around morality is underdeveloped and unaddressed, and the silly comedy – while mostly enjoyable – is established too late?”

The Boy Who Harnessed the Wind

“The Boy Who Harnessed the Wind has heart, and there’s no denying that Kamkwamba’s feat is glorious, but as an audience member, there was a sense of feeling disconnected and distanced from what is happening on stage.”

Choir Boy
Choir Boy

Liam O'Dell · Apr 2, 2026

56

“Choir Boy has charm and wit, and there’s plenty about which you can sing your praises, but it lacks a certain energy to capitalise on its warmth and tenderness.”

John Proctor Is the Villain

“John Proctor is the Villain is a script to be pored over, studied in much the same way the group of Georgia school students analyse Arthur Miller’s The Crucible in Kimberly Belflower’s seven-time Tony Award-nominated play.”

Age Is a Feeling

“You conclude that Age Is A Feeling serves only as a bleak reminder of life’s fleeting nature, with a handful of funny life milestones poking through the morbidity.”

Arcadia
Arcadia

Liam O'Dell · Feb 5, 2026

63

“The second act is at least a lot more dynamic, with a clear conflict between Bernard and couple Valentine and Hannah in which to invest.”

Lost Atoms
Lost Atoms

Liam O'Dell · Feb 4, 2026

39

“The problem is Lost Atoms is too familiar to be a unique and interesting love story, and too wonky to be a powerful piece on loss – despite what its title might suggest about either.”

Ballad Lines
54

“Ballad Lines ultimately presents itself as a story of pregnancy and motherhood, more than it does about bloodlines and songs lasting for generations.”

Beautiful Little Fool

“With solid music, great performances and a decent chronology of the lives of the Fitzgeralds, Beautiful Little Fool is a passable new musical, but it is evidently missing one overarching message it can push emphatically.”

A Ghost in Your Ear

“Eerie and mesmerising, A Ghost in Your Ear feels much longer than a 90-minute thrill in the way in which it completely immerses the listener in the experience.”

Oh, Mary!
Oh, Mary!

Liam O'Dell · Dec 19, 2025

78

“Oh, Mary ! is a fabulous, farcical fever dream. ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ Rating: 4 out of 5.”

All My Sons
All My Sons

Dec 11, 2025

77

“The force underpinning the final hour of acting redeems this production, but with a reinforced focus in the first act, the piece would be more well-rounded and place me with other critics in giving this show all the stars.”

Paddington The Musical

“The warmth and happiness emanating from Paddington the Musical is like one big bear hug – one I imagine many of us didn’t know we needed.”

Porn Play
Porn Play

Liam O'Dell · Nov 17, 2025

41

“The performances are unflinching, and its staging is creative, but in lacking clarity in its narrative and messaging, the same can’t be said for Porn Play’s script.”

Othello
78

“Fierce and passionate performances all-round combined with thrilling finer details make for an exciting watch.”

The Unbelievers
78

“The decision to have actors who are not needed for a particular scene wait upstage in a waiting room is a simple but genius way of reinforcing the show’s themes.”

Hamlet
Hamlet

Liam O'Dell · Oct 5, 2025

55

“Yet there is something about this production which maintains interest, even over an almost three-hour running time.”

Bacchae
Bacchae

Liam O'Dell · Sep 29, 2025

64

“This Bacchae may not always have substance, but it certainly has style.”

The Producers
The Producers

Liam O'Dell · Sep 15, 2025

82

“'The Producers' review - Ridiculous, rapid-fire comedy. Mel Brooks’ musical transfers to the West End’s Garrick Theatre after a sell-out run at Menier Chocolate Factory.”

Born With Teeth

“Gatwa and Bluemel blitz through the 90-minute runtime in what is a ferociously funny – and flirty – production.”

Every Brilliant Thing

“Right now, though, this West End staging is all about the audience participation and interactions, to which Henry is no stranger.”

The Estate
The Estate

Liam O'Dell · Jul 22, 2025

59

“The Estate is written like a precarious political drama, but directed as if it's an insincere comedy.”

Stereophonic
Stereophonic

Liam O'Dell · Jun 15, 2025

71

“Daring direction from Daniel Aukin allows for electric anticipation, and means our attention is maintained across the three-hour runtime.”

The Fifth Step
63

“The point of this 90-minute production, at least to me, seems to be a commentary on interpretation and how we define our reality, but it never quite lands.”

Here We Are
Here We Are

Liam O'Dell · May 10, 2025

18

“The staging of this work after Sondheim’s demise was inevitably faced with a challenge it failed to address, and take on.”

The Brightening Air

“Unfortunately, there's hardly anything visually or narratively engaging about The Brightening Air, other than for Gregory Clarke's sound design and Ben McQuinn on associate music capturing a beautiful, gentle and fascinating ambience which is never really replicated in McPherson's writing and direction, making for a tiring slog of a show instead.”

The Score
The Score

Liam O'Dell · Mar 1, 2025

39

“It's a deeply unfortunate indication of the quality of Cotton's script that I found myself zoning out and nodding off several times in a tedious and wordy first act.”

Unicorn
Unicorn

Liam O'Dell · Feb 14, 2025

77

“You can only just accept this as the story coming together neatly, as opposed to it being cheap, easy writing.”

The Other Place

“The 80 minutes fly by, and that goes to show how gripping this slick, modernised spin on Antigone is.”

Why Am I So Single?

“Six creators Toby Marlow and Lucy Moss return with a fun and relatable musical boasting a strong collection of numbers, but an incredibly thin plot holding them all together.”

Next to Normal
Next to Normal

Jun 30, 2024

80

“In Next To Normal, Brian Yorkey’s book perfectly explores mental health’s impact on several members of a family with commendable, substantive detail – emphasised in Michael Longhurst’s direction.”

Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)

“Equally remarkable is the way in which the numbers reflect the characters singing them. Dougal is afforded bouncy, triplet-style rhythms like those in the idealistic ‘New York!’ while Robin has more pounding ballads to her name (on which Gift triumphs), like ‘What’ll It Be’.”

Machinal
Machinal

Liam O'Dell · Apr 19, 2024

81

“The intent of this production is, very clearly, to establish a sense of unease throughout its almost two-hour long running time (there’s a reason why this unrelenting show does not have an interval).”

Underdog: The Other Other Bronte

“Underdog is clever and very funny – indeed it knows it is – but often gets carried away, tangling itself up in mixed messages and jokes pushed almost to breaking point...”

Nye
Nye

Liam O'Dell · Mar 10, 2024

97

“Nye is, on the whole, a magnificent celebration of our NHS and the man behind it...”

The Little Big Things

“The problem, however, lies in the extent to which The Little Big Things indulges itself in self-pity, despair and tragedy.”

The Pillowman
The Pillowman

Jun 16, 2023

48

“The main three performances are strong nonetheless.”

Oklahoma!
Oklahoma!

Liam O'Dell · Mar 1, 2023

26

“I’m left with a far from beautiful feeling that the direction in Oklahoma! isn’t going the right way at all.”

Medea
Medea

Liam O'Dell · Feb 21, 2023

82

“Dominic Cooke’s 90-minute Medea is engrossing and electric.”

🎭
97

“It’s intense, chilling and gripping, and crackles with such an electrifying, cinematic energy (with credit to Nina Dunn and Gino Ricardo Green for truly elemental video design).”

The Crucible
The Crucible

Liam O'Dell · Sep 29, 2022

62

“The acting is rich and gripping, and the staging gorgeous, but for those wishing for something beyond the aesthetics, I fear this Crucible falls short.”

The Seagull
The Seagull

Liam O'Dell · Aug 31, 2022

41

“Even if Jamie Lloyd's slow pacing is deliberate, it's mumbling misery.”

Cruise
Cruise

Liam O'Dell · Aug 18, 2022

86

“Holden’s play is as much a dizzying dash back as it is a hopeful look and drive forwards.”

Manor
Manor

Liam O'Dell · Nov 23, 2021

45

“There are some interesting moments on the gaslighting of minorities by the far-right, but there’s hardly anything revelatory in Manor’s interrogation of fringe politics – instead it struggles to find something original.”

Rare Earth Mettle

“While questions are raised over the main satire at the heart of Rare Earth Mettle, I’m also left wondering what exactly the point is behind the actors engaging in elaborate dance numbers to electronic music in between scenes.”

Is God Is
Is God Is

Liam O'Dell · Sep 16, 2021

80

“Visually, the production is stunning and subversive, with Chloe Lamford building upon the playful pacing and direction of Ince.”

Uncle Vanya
Uncle Vanya

Liam O'Dell · Jan 25, 2020

75

“The lack of energy may be the biggest tragedy for some, but that may well be the point in this otherwise powerfully performed, character-driven musing on existentialism.”

Lungs
Lungs

Liam O'Dell · Nov 4, 2019

78

“Smith and Foy navigate the issue of climate change on Rob Howell (Matilda)’s smart, minimalist stage with the urgency one would expect.”