Skip to main content

WhatsOnStage

Tier 2: Major outlet. Counts ¾ as much as a Tier 1 review.

Reviews

415

Average

75

Highest

100

Lowest

12

17th most prolific outlet·367th most generous scorer·31 different critics
SORT:
From The Heart
55

“From The Heart is a very pleasant 80 minutes, although it sometimes feels like a show mounted more for friends and family rather than West End audiences.”

Jane Eyre
78

“This revival – co-produced by the Mercury, Rose Theatre Kingston, Storyhouse Chester and Northern Stage in Newcastle – brings back one of literature’s great anti-heroes, Edward Rochester.”

Rent
Rent

Sarah Crompton · Oct 8, 2026

82

“All in all, this is a hugely enjoyable revival of a musical that is standing the test of time, even as it conjures stories from the past.”

Affluenza
15

“The frankly ludicrous sequencing of events thereafter undermines any attempt to develop a coherent theme.”

The Hungry Ghost

“For a first-time playwright, The Hungry Ghost is a confident and wonderfully original piece of writing, and one that leaves its audience hungry for whatever Yew serves up next.”

Hay Fever
82

“At its best moments, this production of Hay Fever works like a well-oiled clock, each of its comedic elements clicking neatly into place.”

Tru
Tru

Sonny Waheed · Sep 27, 2026

78

“Tru delivers a beautifully realised evening in the company of one of the great wits of the last century, led by an understatedly magnetic Ferguson.”

Table 17
Table 17

Hang Yuen · Sep 25, 2026

76

“If you happen to be in the neighbourhood, be sure to take a seat at Table 17.”

Three Men in a Boat

“Following three friends and a dog as they take a calamitous boat trip up the Thames from Kingston to Oxford, Al Smith’s madcap new version is stupendously silly and full of frivolous fun.”

The Last Ship
The Last Ship

Alex Wood · Sep 23, 2026

61

“Sting gives a spirited performance as the illness-riddled foreman Jackie White, bringing his real-life experience living in Wallsend and landing the show some-much needed heart.”

The Turn of the Screw

“The doubling of Miles and Flora with the silent adult roles of Quint and Jessel was borne of necessity (as Lloyd Malcolm’s programme note explains) but it succeeds in complicating the disturbing relationships between the children and the deceased adults even further.”

Thelma & Louise: A New Musical

“But it all feels meagre, slow-paced, stripped of excitement and crucially of that sense of liberation which powers the narrative even as it dips towards its inevitable close.”

Twenty Thousand Streets

“Technically, it’s striking and impressive but a fine production can’t quite compensate for the fact that, in turning three books into a fairly short play with only six actors, Reader’s adaptation sometimes feels like a symphony rescored for a sextet who can’t quite hit the right notes.”

Darkling
Darkling

Alexander Cohen · Sep 16, 2026

62

“Frustrated by stunted writing, Darkling doesn’t penetrate beyond the surface level of its ideas.”

Golden Boy
Golden Boy

Sarah Crompton · Sep 16, 2026

82

“But in a production as good as this one by Sam Yates and with a forceful central performance by Josh O’Connor as Joe Bonaparte, violinist turned boxer in Depression-era America, it makes its case as a powerful, admonitory slice of theatre noir.”

Million Dollar Quartet

“The production works best when it embraces itself as an exuberant celebration of 1950s music: joyful, nostalgic and irresistible, but attempts to add greater historical or dramatic weight instead expose thin characterisation, particularly for Elvis Presley and Johnny Cash.”

The Children
86

“What I expected to be a nice, sweet Friday-night post-work watch turned out to be funny, thought-provoking, unsettling and ultimately deeply moving.”

Man to Man
Man to Man

Alex Wood · Sep 13, 2026

82

“A play written in the 1980s speaks loudly today and makes another fine addition to the Royal Court’s 70th anniversary season.”

Tartuffe Remixed
Tartuffe Remixed

Sep 11, 2026

82

“As a show, it’s as big of heart as it’s loud of mouth and, ultimately, just an awful lot of fun.”

Jane Eyre
66

“However, although it doesn’t quite convince as an overlooked masterpiece, there is no doubt it has merits, together with some stonking central performances, and is one that musical aficionados won’t want to miss.”

Kimberly Akimbo

“No wonder that it won five Tonys, including Best Musical, when it appeared on Broadway in 2022 (after an off-Broadway run the previous year).”

Holy Fool
Holy Fool

Miriam Sallon · Sep 4, 2026

35

“Other than this, the evening is neither offensive nor intriguing, but largely forgettable, a shame given what it might have been.”

The Story
65

“Dyer’s direction is superbly confident, and beautifully realised as characters speak and argue in parallel scenes.”

A Month in the Country

“It’s a gloriously rich play, wonderfully realised in a production that holds its contradictions gently in its hands and just lets its subtleties reveal themselves.”

Who Killed Marilyn?

“If ChatGPT were commissioned to write a play about Marilyn Monroe, it would probably look a lot like this.”

Death Note: The Musical

“Ultimately, the worst thing about Death Note: The Musical is the fact that it’s only at the Barbican for a mere five weeks.”

I'm Every Woman
I'm Every Woman

Aug 5, 2026

35

“This disappointing musical sounds less like an affair played on a jukebox and more a set of tunes assembled by someone learning to scratch.”

Dog Man - The Musical

“However, if you’re just looking for some lo-fi family-friendly fun with a few good songs, I’d hold on for panto season.”

The Car Man
97

“Bold, sexy, theatrical and thoroughly entertaining, The Car Man proves to remain a standout in the New Adventures repertoire.”

Tao of Glass
73

“It’s fantastical and disarming in a way that normally seems out of reach for adult theatre.”

Cleansed
Cleansed

Miriam Sallon · Jul 30, 2026

74

“Performances are faultless; deeply unsettling and heartrending in equal measure, except Leo Bill’s Tinker, who is only the former.”

Midnight at the Never Get

“This is a rare opportunity to see a singular talent at the top of his game giving full virtuoso flex to material that feels ripe with embryonic potential.”

Hole!
Hole!

Miriam Sallon · Jul 20, 2026

80

“It’s the scrappy upstart to The Book of Mormon’s slick West End production; a winning combination of nerdy musical theatre and boundary-pushing obscenities.”

The Oresteia
The Oresteia

Matt Trueman · Jul 15, 2026

80

“The second act of Simon Stone’s The Oresteia is one of the most gripping, visceral and biting hours of drama you are ever likely to see on stage.”

Heathers the Musical
78

“Darkly funny with a talented cast to boot, this cult classic will have you laughing when you shouldn’t and reflecting on your teenage years and the emotional rollercoaster of those raging hormones and the complexities of adolescent friendships.”

Jesus Christ Superstar

“In Timothy Sheader’s immaculate production – first seen to Olivier-winning effect at Regent’s Park 10 years ago, and harnessing Drew McOnie’s pin-sharp choreography – this is a religious leader ensnared by his own cult.”

The Guilty
60

“I couldn’t suspend my disbelief, so I was always distanced from what is undoubtedly an extraordinarily gripping and clever piece.”

A Midsummer Night's Dream

“But perhaps in an attempt to attract a less likely audience, Banerjee has drowned all of this in a wash of wholesomeness and uncomplicated joy, which might sound nice but makes for a boring production.”

Relics
Relics

Alun Hood · Jun 30, 2026

83

“Relics is terrific entertainment that is also about something urgent and relatable.”

Archduke
Archduke

Sarah Crompton · Jun 29, 2026

65

“But amidst the mayhem, it’s sometimes difficult to discern what the overall point is.”

Pride
Pride

Sarah Crompton · Jun 26, 2026

82

“The euphoria of the show’s conclusion, marking an event that really did change people and perceptions, is impossible to resist.”

Cyrano de Bergerac

“Adrian Lester delivers his best performance in donkeys’ years as Cyrano, at times playfully camp, other times sardonically steely as the tragic hero.”

The Truth
The Truth

Theo Bosanquet · Jun 25, 2026

81

“It all makes for a smart piece of summer programming, a fun Parisian romp with an intriguing note of melancholy.”

Hot Mess: A New Musical

“A hot, sexy and unexpectedly poignant musical that feels both entertaining and urgently relevant.”

Sinatra The Musical

“Dramatically inert but musically magnificent, this is a solid tribute to a singular talent, and will undoubtedly prove a glamorous summer hit.”

Sting
Sting

Julia Rank · Jun 24, 2026

59

“Swithinbank is clearly talented, and there’s real richness, viscerality and compassion in her ideas and writing style, but greater attention to detail is needed in order to make the piece resonate without distraction.”

The Misanthrope

“This is a Misanthrope full of interesting ideas and fine effects, but not quite enough bite or fury.”

Glengarry Glen Ross

“This new production, directed by Patrick Marber, has an all-female cast and a shifted perspective that is bold and thought-provoking, if not always theatrically successful.”

Under the Shadow

“It can’t sustain the delicate balance it has created – but it is undoubtedly both original and enjoyable.”

Allegra
Allegra

Aliya Al-Hassan · Jun 9, 2026

67

“Lipman is a delight to watch in this nostalgic and touching play.”

Are You Watching?

“Jess Edwards’ intense, superbly acted production is a masterpiece of controlled chaos, balancing the artificial with raw anguish and gallows humour.”

High Society
High Society

Alex Wood · Jun 3, 2026

82

“Happily, Rachel Kavanaugh’s production does almost everything right, matching Kiss Me, Kate and only fractionally short of Anything Goes, in being a lavish, big-hearted revival that never leaves its audience shortchanged: a swellegant, elegant party indeed.”

War Horse
War Horse

Jane Kemp · Jun 3, 2026

100

“It earns its tears honestly, which is rarer than it sounds; grown adults leave looking like they’ve taken a part-time job chopping onions.”

Beetlejuice
Beetlejuice

Alex Wood · May 29, 2026

68

“It means the show is constantly an amusing ride, but never really flashes its teeth.”

Redcliffe
96

“With over 21 songs, Luke Gage has created a masterpiece of a musical on queer love which uplifts, entertains and unites.”

End of the Rainbow
60

“Her energy, commitment, and skills as a comic and mimic are tremendous, but ultimately this feels more like a highly accomplished impersonation than a fully rounded characterisation.”

CARE
CARE

Sarah Crompton · May 20, 2026

85

“Its tender truthfulness makes Care a great play.”

Equus
Equus

Sarah Crompton · May 19, 2026

89

“Together, they allow Equus once again to cast its spell as an outstanding and gripping piece of storytelling, a great leap of theatrical imagination.”

Sherlock Holmes

“The design is indeed rather more subtle than some of the writing which has the obviousness of a hammer blow, and a plot that twists and turns bewilderingly before ending up where Holmes enthusiasts might always have guessed it would land.”

The Last Man
35

“Unfortunately even a fantastic performance can’t redeem a piece with no content.”

1536
1536

Alex Wood · May 13, 2026

97

“It’s a bold, essential piece of theatre that the West End should always look to have on its stages.”

Krapp’s Last Tape/Godot’s To-Do List

“He isn’t either as moving or as desperate as some of his predecessors in the role, adopting a richer voice for the recording and a reedy growl as the older Krapp querulously interjects about the younger man’s foolishness.”

Grace Pervades

“Miranda Raison brings her to wonderfully spirited, clever life, as the play examines her relationship with Henry Irving.”

Tender by Dave Harris

“Tender is a wildly entertaining play that balances comedy with emotional depth, while sharing a unique exploration of masculinity.”

The Price
The Price

Alun Hood · Apr 24, 2026

82

“Nobody strips bare carefully constructed characters and the downside of the American Dream like Arthur Miller, and if this isn’t one of his absolute best, it’s still a damn satisfying evening in the theatre, especially in as fine a production as this one.”

Between The River and The Sea

“Sweid is an extraordinarily engaging presence. He flirts with the audience, turning emotions this way and that, never losing the thread of the complexity of the ideas he wants to convey.”

Avenue Q
Avenue Q

Alun Hood · Apr 17, 2026

97

“Decades on, Avenue Q remains a delight, the theatrical definition of naughty but nice.”

Heart Wall
62

“Heart Wall is poignant and thought-provoking: with a tighter focus, it could deliver even more impact.”

Dear Jack, Dear Louise

“Dear Jack, Dear Louise is a sweet story full of wit and goodness and a sense that everything will be alright in the end.”

FLYBY
FLYBY

Lucinda Everett · Apr 10, 2026

62

“These sections add less, and indeed it is the show’s space-escape premise that proves its biggest challenge.”

Copenhagen
82

“Alex Kingston is simply superb as Margrethe, bringing a sardonic tone of reality to the men's endless debate.”

Romeo and Juliet

“If it isn’t quite up there with Icke’s best, that’s only because he has set the bar so high.”

WhatsOnStage - Theatre Reviews (Tier 2) | Broadway Scorecard