“A kind of magical alchemy... renders the musical version far more satisfying.” By Roma Torre, Oct 14, 2025

Bull Durham: A New Musical
Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn, NJ
Opened Oct 12, 2025 · Closed Nov 2, 2025 · Ran for 1 month
Regional production: tracked as a buzzy, well-reviewed show that could transfer to Broadway.
Critics' Take coming soon.
This show has closed. Tickets are no longer available.
Critic Scorecard
6 reviews- Tier 1: 100%
- Tier 2: 75%
- Tier 3: 40%
- Tier 4: 20%
“The company’s acting and vocal talents are exceptional... a winning show.” By Marina Kennedy, Oct 15, 2025
“No revelation... but a reliably entertaining, feel-good kind of show.” By Jay Lustig, Oct 17, 2025
“Bull Durham isn’t ready for the Major Leagues... thank goodness for Cusack.” By Ryan Leeds, Oct 13, 2025
“Comes across as not only deliberate but also miscalculated... they needed to dumb it down.” By Laura Collins-Hughes, Oct 22, 2025






