Best Broadway Shows of All Time

Every Broadway show we've scored, ranked by aggregated CriticScore ratings from dozens of professional critics and publications. This isn't a popularity contest or a list of personal favorites — it's a data-driven ranking based on the collective judgment of theater critics across The New York Times, Variety, Vulture, and dozens more. From recent hits to classic revivals, these rankings span decades of Broadway history. Whether you're settling a debate or discovering your next obsession, this is the most comprehensive critical ranking of Broadway shows available anywhere.

728 shows | Last updated: September 2026